So now having agreed that Isa(AS) is still a prophet and will return as a prophet
phew, finally!
- Will Jesus (as) be on the shria of hazrat Moosa(as) when he comes back?
- If he is to come as an ummati of the holy prophet (saw), what happens to the ayah in the qura'an saying he is a messenger to bani-israel? will that verse be no longer valid?
- If he doesn't come with the sharia of hazrat Moosa (as), then what happens to awamir-o-nawahi? what will he enjoin to do and what will he stop people from?
- If he is going to preach the sharia of the Holy Prophet (saw), then who will teach him this sharia? will it be the ulema or will God directly teach him?
[quote]
your next question will be:
"then how can we claim the end of prophethood if he is going to be a prophet on his return?"
The answer to this is again semantics. The thing is he (AS) is not a new prophet and will be a returning prophet with a different set of missions one of which is to destroy Dajjal, another is to demonstrate the clear obedience to Islam and unite the Muslims and humanity in general. None of these objectives make him a new prophet, however, to be born after the prophet Muhammad (SAW) and to receive wahi and to make claim to prophethood where previously that claim was not made does infer a new prophetic claim and that is why we do not accept Mirza Ghulam Ahmad saab as Isa (AS).
[/QUOTE]
That's quite a weak argument. Lets say today a child is born while a man is 25 years old. The child dies in a few days, but the man lives for 80 years. Who would a historian call last?
I wonder why you brought Mirza sahib in. The topic of the thread is all about jesus so lets stick to the topic shall we?