Re: Is it wrong
yeh dunyaa meN meHv ho jaane aur Allah se door ho jaane kii baat hai aur Ghaflat baratne ke silsile se hai. jo log iimaan laaye aur 5 sutoon qaayam kiye un par yeh aayat/aayaat laazim nahiiN aatiiN…
…someone said, it’s bid’a…the definition of bid’a is…“to do something thinking that it’s part of Deen and expect a reward for in doing it and gunaah in abandoning it”.
i don’t think any of us do that as a partt of deen or expect sawaab.
i’m NOT saying it’s oerfect to celebrate…of course NOT…this is a matter of taqwa. the more mutaqqi you are the more you will refrain from doing something which falls in the grey area of deen.
it’s NOT a big deal to take the kids for trick or treating but it’s ok if kids enjoy a bit. i’m sure we commit a lot of minor sins knowingly and unknowingly and Allah is most Gracious and most Forgiving.