Re: is it sharia?
I am extremely disturbed by this. I don't think anyone deserves this humiliation or punishment. No matter what she did.
So lets start stoning to death, its really easy to say that while sitting in the offices & drawing rooms.
Islam doesn't allow selective following but lets have a Ijtihad on it, we can't apply certain Shariaah rules in today's world, we just can't. They are consider unhuman & atrocities against humanity.
One example can be "Hadood Laws" which were repelled by President Musharraf in 2004, how can a women produce two witness after she got raped? This is just sick.
Who decides what is 'inhuman' or 'atrocity' in today's world? The president of the USA?
I would say the American actions in Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan and Israels actions in Palestine, Jordan and Syria are much more inhumane, insane and sick.
^ and what about the American leadership?
Im assuming you're joking....right? That can be the only explanation of you defending this act OR trying to justify it by saying something so immature. Meaning, its okay for this to occur? You dont really care about the humiliation/degradation/abuse of women, you just want to point fingers at a gora somehow right? Its all a gora's fault right? We're all innocent, its the white man doing this? Yup!
Im living in Chicago so you presume to think Im going to support American leadership if it were to do something like this? Wow. Talk about narrow-minded and barbaric views...but then again...it takes all kinds to make the world go round...even yours.
Grow up.
Who decides what is 'inhuman' or 'atrocity' in today's world? The president of the USA?
I would say the American actions in Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan and Israels actions in Palestine, Jordan and Syria are much more inhumane, insane and sick.
This isnt about AMERICA...get over it.
Re: is it sharia?
^ I am not defending anyone. Was just wondering if barbarism by usa (much worse than taliban's) is not noticed here. 'Drone attack kills 17 civilians' is a one liner in the news.
Anyways, I was 'off-topic'.... my apologies.
Who decides what is 'inhuman' or 'atrocity' in today's world? The president of the USA?
I would say the American actions in Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan and Israels actions in Palestine, Jordan and Syria are much more inhumane, insane and sick.
Look dude, you seriously need to get off America from your head. You notion of .."har kam k peechey America hai" .. its wrong.. get over it !
Re: is it sharia?
Its not me. All the human rights groups condemn american actions there. I wonder if you consider guys attacking iraq and afghanistan 'stateless actors'?
Anyways, as previously said, this is not about usa. Leave it here.
Re: is it sharia?
No it is not . Sadly instead of merging their tribal system with Islam , they are labelling their silly rituals as Islamic laws
Am just down here from a month or so and believe me it aint a place to live your life ! or where you want your kids to be raised !
Re: is it sharia?
america is another issue.but this is disgusting and horrible thing to do.whoever they r. r they taliban or others.
Re: is it sharia?
@ firenze,
okay, for instance, we consider that it is in accordance with Islam.. then:
- why it is being said on television that this happened before shariah law was implemented? a defensive approach..
- why it is being said by a taliban representative that those ppl were not from them?
- why one of the representative of shariah law implementers, is saying this is not in accordance with ISLAM and those ppl must be brought to task??
any explanation?
either the link u gave is a fake bayaan, or ppl who are pretendin to be representatives of shariah law implementers or talibaan are fake..????
@ firenze,
okay, for instance, we consider that it is in accordance with Islam.. then:
- why it is being said on television that this happened before shariah law was implemented? a defensive approach..
- why it is being said by a taliban representative that those ppl were not from them?
- why one of the representative of shariah law implementers, is saying this is not in accordance with ISLAM and those ppl must be brought to task??
any explanation?
either the link u gave is a fake bayaan, or ppl who are pretendin to be representatives of shariah law implementers or talibaan are fake..????
Look dude all i know .. is this punshiment is in Shariaah.. but i don't approve it as human being.
So what do you want me to say ?
Re: is it sharia?
i mean, if it is in accordance wo shariah, then it shd not be denied by these Aalims..
i mean, if it is in accordance wo shariah, then it shd not be denied by these Aalims..
They are not denying they are saying.. these can be only given by government not individuals.
Re: is it sharia?
Firenze , there is nothing wrong with these Islamic laws ... but they are Implementing them in a wrong way ... without a fear of accountability !
Firenze , there is nothing wrong with these Islamic laws ... *but they are Implementing them in a wrong way ... without a fear of accountability * !
Implementing, you gotta be kidding me, we can't implement them, these laws are not for today. I would suggest for UNO to designate a special land where all the Shariaah lovers can live according to their own rules !
Some inhabitant island will work ..
Implementing, you gotta be kidding me, we can't implement them, these laws are not for today. I would suggest for UNO to designate a special land where all the Shariaah lovers can live according to their own rules !
Some inhabitant island will work ..
Ya did a very well mocking job here , bravo ....
As a muslim , we all believe that Islam and Islamic laws ( if correctly implemented ) are for every era and time...
And kindly don’t worry about getting a piece of land for sharia lovers ( the righteous ones ).. if they don’t get a place here , they will be getting one in heaven for sure ..
Same as you cant hate USA and American people for the acts done by their present or past governments , ya cant badmouth about the religion and its laws , the religion which was sent for whole humanity ...
Implementing, you gotta be kidding me, we can't implement them, these laws are not for today. I would suggest for UNO to designate a special land where all the Shariaah lovers can live according to their own rules !
Some inhabitant island will work ..
These laws are in effect in Saudi Arabia.
These laws are in effect in Saudi Arabia.
They are not, Shariaah is for selected individual's only in Saudia.
Ya did a very well mocking job here , bravo ....
*As a muslim , we all believe that Islam and Islamic laws ( if correctly implemented ) are for every era and time... *
And kindly don’t worry about getting a piece of land for sharia lovers ( the righteous ones ).. if they don’t get a place here , they will be getting one in heaven for sure ..
Same as you cant hate USA and American people for the acts done by their present or past governments , ya cant badmouth about the religion and its laws , the religion which was sent for whole humanity ...
what do you mean by if correctly implemented? Lets have a poll today with-in Pakistan and show them this video and ask them would they want this to be implemented? Majority will say NO.. so here goes our so-called Islamic laws or divine one's. Recent example was hadood laws which was changed by President Musharraf how many people came to streets for protests ?
Ground realities are changed, no one will accept these punishments or laws except some pseudo mullahs to be implemented. Show me a recent example with-in last 1000 years where Shariaah is implemented. No their is no example, always it goes down either from with-in or outside.
You can suppress the society with these punishments, one way or other it will be brought down by the same people !
The righteous one already found a speedy way, just blow yourself and you are in Jannat.