lekin Muhatram Munir Niazi aur Janab Faiz Ahmed Faiz Sahib ne koi Jawab nahin likha iss tarah ke ashaar likhne ke baad na hi Ghalib ne koi Wazahat farmai ke un ke nazdeek Jannat ka wajood kin maani main mashkook tha. :)
tu janab yehi tu maay aap ko itni dair say farma raha hoon k janab mujhay batain k iqbal nay kahan likha hai kahan irshad farmaya hai kis banday k kaan may kaha hai k bhai jin molvi hazraat ko shikway ki samjh nahi aa saki un k liyay may nay jawab-e-shikwa wazahat may likha hai....please give me specific link...and i will agree to you.
tu janab yehi tu maay aap ko itni dair say farma raha hoon k janab mujhay batain k iqbal nay kahan likha hai kahan irshad farmaya hai kis banday k kaan may kaha hai k bhai jin molvi hazraat ko shikway ki samjh nahi aa saki un k liyay may nay jawab-e-shikwa wazahat may likha hai....please give me specific link...and i will agree to you.
Who said ke Allama gave a statement? Allama presnted his view in 'jawab e Shikwa', whereas others poets whose ashar we have discussed din't give any explanatory statement or a poem explaining their position. simple as that.
I think every poet should write an explanatory paragraph stating wht the poem is about.It would make things a whole lot simpler.Specially for people like me :D
Who said ke Allama gave a statement? Allama presnted his view in 'jawab e Shikwa', whereas others poets whose ashar we have discussed din't give any explanatory statement or a poem explaining their position. simple as that.
ok iqbaliyaat may kisi bhi mahir ka mujhay link shair kar dain k iqbal nay jawab-e-shikwa aap ki understanding k accordingly likha...specific answer..
I think every poet should write an explanatory paragraph stating wht the poem is about.It would make things a whole lot simpler.Specially for people like me :D
thats a good idea...lets start an online petition against this suggestion... :p lolz
nope…may chahta hoon tum meri sab say achi student banoo poetry explanation may :), i am also a student in this and i love to think long hours even during development(software) to know the hidden meanings of a shair :)…
