tu janab yehi tu maay aap ko itni dair say farma raha hoon k janab mujhay batain k iqbal nay kahan likha hai kahan irshad farmaya hai kis banday k kaan may kaha hai k bhai jin molvi hazraat ko shikway ki samjh nahi aa saki un k liyay may nay jawab-e-shikwa wazahat may likha hai…please give me specific link…and i will agree to you.
Who said ke Allama gave a statement? Allama presnted his view in ‘jawab e Shikwa’, whereas others poets whose ashar we have discussed din’t give any explanatory statement or a poem explaining their position. simple as that.
I think every poet should write an explanatory paragraph stating wht the poem is about.It would make things a whole lot simpler.Specially for people like me
nope…may chahta hoon tum meri sab say achi student banoo poetry explanation may :), i am also a student in this and i love to think long hours even during development(software) to know the hidden meanings of a shair :)…