Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

An Elizabethtown College religion professor has written a book that presents Hinduism as the ‘universal’ religion, capable of providing a model for global inter-religious cooperation and world peace.

“A Vision for Hinduism: Beyond Hindu Nationalism - By Jeffrey Long


An Elizabethtown College religion professor has written a book that presents Hinduism as the ‘universal’ religion, capable of providing a model for global inter-religious cooperation and world peace.

“A Vision for Hinduism: Beyond Hindu Nationalism” builds upon Jeffery Long’s arguments for religious pluralism developed in his doctoral dissertation for the University of Chicago. In his book, he argues for a traditional pluralistic understanding of Hinduism – as articulated by such figures as Sri Ramakrishna and Mahatma Gandhi – in opposition to the narrow identification of Hinduism with Indian nationality and ethnicity that characterizes contemporary Hindu nationalist movements.

Long asserts that Hindu nationalism is not only destructive of communal relations, but that it also prevents Hinduism from emerging as a world religion in the true sense of the term. He presents a vision of Hinduism as a tradition capable of pointing the way toward a future in which all the world’s religions manifest complementary visions of a larger reality - and in which they all, in various ways, participate.

Reviews of Long’s manuscript have described it as “both highly relevant and timely” and “fascinating, ambitious and represents an important foray into inter-religious exchange.”

Long has taught at Elizabethtown College since receiving his doctoral degree at the University of Chicago in 2000. He is the author of the forthcoming “Jainism: An Introduction” and has published in Prabuddha Bharata, The Journal of Religion, Science and Spirit, Creative Transformations and several edited volumes. Long has presented papers for a variety of scholarly organizations, including the American Academy of Religion, the Association for Asian Studies, and the Society for Asian and Comparative Philosophy.

Ranked as one of the best colleges in the northern United States by U.S. News and World Report, Elizabethtown offers its 1900 students 53 academic programs in the liberal arts, sciences and professional studies. Driven by its motto to “Educate for Service,” Elizabethtown centers learning in strong relationships, links classroom instruction with experiential learning, emphasizes international and cross-cultural perspectives and nurtures the capacity for lives of purpose.

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

these kind of backwaas threads have been discussed before after an ass called Nicols_john opened such threads. can go and watch them for more details.

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

there are few things we as humans cant go out of
1-love for parents even if they were serial killers
2-love for country even its doing crime like usa or india
3-love for relegion even if it is worshiping shiv ling

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion’?

You are right.

Hindu nationalism is not only destructive of communal relations, but that it also prevents Hinduism from emerging as a world religion in the true sense of the term. He presents a vision of Hinduism as a tradition capable of pointing the way toward a future in which all the world’s religions manifest complementary visions of a larger reality - and in which they all, in various ways, participate.

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

why u love allah?? thosuands of people have been killed on the name of allah. No human or animal life is affetced when i workship shivling.
u kill thousands of animals on eid.

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

For what i've heard, according to Hinduism one doesn't have to be Hindu to gain salvation. He just needs to do good deeds, karma, and he/she 'll be fine. Ofcourse, good karma excludes all muslims. okay, here it goes, banned again.

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

Is Jeffrey hindu himself

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

as being a muslim, we love Allah, coz our Islam preach us to do so...
we slaughter many animals on eid coz Islam teach us to do so.....
and
we learn Islam by Holy Quran
and Holy prophets
all previous messengers those who sent by Allah to us preached us to sacrifice animals.
so we learn it by these two sources

1.QURAN
2.HOLY PROPHET

and both of these sources are not made by us.....

ALLAH create them all.

besides all these u follow shivling.......

WHY.....

any prove to follow it????
u just follow coz u find ur family to follow it...
n nothing else....
there is nothing in ur religion that CAME from Allah (the creator of all world)
so
ur religion is only based on stories of ur forefathers

if u want to see the difference between the religions, want to see right and wrong.....
dont follow others, not even ur religious preachers

read any GOOD, AUTHENTIC book on COMPARITIVE STUDY.

u will inshaAllah find the path to truth...................IF U REALLY WANT

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

Be patient chintu bhopali, I thought you are guy who lives and let lives, and if someone comments on Hinduism, you prounce on it, like a hawk. Just forget it but since, you have touched on another baseless comment fo Islam, let me enlighten you with, what Islam is all about.

Is this the criterion to believe in Allaah, let me know adn then we will go ahead. Who is asking you to do all this, fine you can still remain a good muslim without doing all this.

These are not obligatory principle of Islam, the most important is believing in One Unseen God, Creator, The Most Merciful. Once you believe one True God, then you submit your will to God thats what a Muslim.

Who is asking any Muslim to do all these things, without believing in Allaah, you still remain a Good muslim without doing all these rituals.

But, if you do it its good for us, simple. Agar eid ki baat kar hi dete hoto, dont fall into this trap just leave it, its baseless arguments, which are not even Primary reason for Islam to grow.

Thanks.

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

So u mean to say i am not made by god and my religion is not made by god(then why we say everything belongs to god)?
i assume that then allah rules only muslims and rest kafirs are ruled by some other god?
what difference it makes in ur life by following islam or any other religion?
dont u breathe? dont u eat? do u have a good luck in compared to kafirs?

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

see bro.. i believe in allah as much as i believe in my hindu religion. i dont point finger on any religion nor i want some stupid ass to point finger on my religion.
noone has seen god and its use less to say that my religion is superior to urs.
everything is equal in eyes of god.** if u do gud karma god will be happy irrespective of ur religion.**
btw its my birthday today so dont forget to wish me:D

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

Hindus damn care for that. In fact mostly Hindus have no complexes regarding religion and they do not die hard to prove the superiority of their religion.

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

Many many happy returns of the day first. Well thats nice, curious to know how old are you and where do you live, great to know.

Secondly to the topic, I never say any religion is superior thats wrong, I always say any way of life which is towards the truth, so that falsehood perishes.

Like, karma good deed are important, and being righteous is also important. Moreover, i feel personally submitting your will to God gives utmost satisfaction or I should use the word Nirvana for better understanding.

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

I believe Islam is the most peaceful religion.. Atleast Muslims don't fight like the Hindus(North Indians Vs. South Indians, Nepalis Vs. Bhutanese, LTTE vs. Sri Lankans, Assam, Tamil Nadu- there's so much violence in India everywhere).

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

In scriptures any religion is peaceful.

In real life there is no peace, for that matter all religions are into hellholes. Some are in a deep abyss in comparision to others but all are in abyss.

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

[QUOTE]
Atleast Muslims don't fight like the Hindus(North Indians Vs. South Indians, Nepalis Vs. Bhutanese, LTTE vs. Sri Lankans, Assam, Tamil Nadu- there's so much violence in India everywhere).
[/QUOTE]

1) N Indians Vs. S Indians
duh.......
(Probably my IQ is bad or I never knew my homeland as well as you did. Never heard of such a thing)

2)Nepalis Vs Bhutanese
Never heard of that either. And bhutanese are mainly Buddhists.

3)LTTE vs. Sri Lankans
Sri Lankans are mainly Buddhists. And this conflict has got nothing to do with religions.

4)Assam, Tamil Nadu
What happenned to Tamil Nadu??!!
And the conflict in Assam hasn't got anything to do with religion either.

5)there's so much violence in India everywhere.
Really?!

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

Dear moin.ul.atiq

Since you seem to know so much about India and Hindus, I will ask you some questions. 

You say Muslims don't fight like Hindus.
I can understand this in two ways- you are probably saying that Hindus fight against other religion, or maybe they fight against themselves, much more than Muslims.
The first possibility is ruled out coz Hinduism never expanded the way Islam did, by the sword. In fact, it never quite expanded at all.

Regarding the second possibility, can you enlighten me by showing a SINGLE example of Shaivites killing Vaishnavas, etc....?( Don't think abt Caste system- that's a social evil, which makes it quite different from sectarian violence)

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

Bhai

Seekh taako deejiye jaako seekh suhaye,
Seekh na deeje vanara jo ghar bahi jaaye.

You educate a person who deserves to be educated.
Don't educate a monkey who can destroy your abode (Remember ancient folk tale 'Monkey and the Weaver Bird').

Some people wear lenses of hatred and are hard wired for hatred and animosity. I have several Muslims friends and none of them have such attitudes. People don't understand that hating others also inflicts damage on them.

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

First of all the starters of such threads, before starting any topic related with Sanatan Dharma should consider that this is a forum where majority of believers are Muslims, so comments which are offensive might come.

Secondly, the professor who is mentioned in the thread is not aware that the name "Hinduism" itself is like a popular name rather than correct description. I have never read any word like "Hindu" in any of Vedas, Upnishads or even Puranas, so I still wonder from from where this word "Hinduism" started gaining popularity. In fact word Hindu has nothing to do with Vedic Sanatan Dharma.

Now, even if one writes entire book about Sanatan Dharma, one may not be able to finish defining this most ancient dharma in Universe.

Thousands of yogis/ascetics/sadhus/hermits renounce their materialistic desires for one and only purpose "Self-Realization".
Unlike all other man made/revealed religions, Sanatan Dharma is an eternal experience, nothing but "Self-Realization".
This never requires you for spreading your experience through conversion, neither it says that that non-followers will be subjected to hell fire. This is because of simple fact that "self-realization" is a personal experience!!!.
Due to no-compulsion and tolerant nature of Sanatan Dharma at some point ignorants consider this as something similiar to"atheism" or no-belief etc.Absence of any compulsion, is the main reason why since ancient times India accommodated so many beliefs and religions.

In fact Sanatan Dharma never commands that it is the only way to attain liberation. It's one of the several ways, and it gives Human being space to realize on their own.
In every Yuga (or age/period) including Kaliyuga (that is the present time), many have achieved the state of "Self-Realization" and have described their experiences and ways through which they realised the "absolute truth" in their own ways. Sanatan Dharma can also be called as a comilation of all such experiences and practices.
Many of the "self-realized" or enlightened souls have preferred to stay in recluse, therefore their own experiences and ways are still unknown. However very few of them who have shared it with their disciples/followers.
The most notable among them is Adi Sankara. After Realizing the "Supreme Truth"" or "God" or "Brahman" he shared this with His disciples. Accordingly He established "Advaita Vedanta" which literally means non-dualism and explains Vedas realized by Him.
Many more enlightened souls like Madhavacarya have further shared their Knowledge of "Dvaita".
This continues till today and we have known many more enlightened souls like Swami Ramkrishna Paramhans and His disciples including Swami Vivekananda. Swami Mahavatar and his line of disciples starting from Swami Lahiri Mahasaya, Swami Yukteswar and most recently Swami Paramhansa Yogananda who revealed the western people the unknown practice of "Kriya Yoga".
Reading about each and every individual who has realized the "Absolute Truth" or "God" only enhances the Knowledge. It is same like reading any revealed books of other faiths adds to knowledge. "Self-Realization" is practically a personal experience and doesnot require anyone to follow a prophet or revealed scripture. Though a Sadguru or a Prophet can rightly guide a human and share with Him his own ways since He Himself has realized the "Supreme".

Re: Is Hinduism a ‘Universal’ Religion'?

Salam to all hindu friends.....

As a muslim ....it is obligatory for me and all of the muslims that we respect other religion whatsoever ......It is written in quran that do not say any bad word to thier gods(as people of makkah worshipped 360 idols placed in kkaaba) so that they would not say a bad word to Allah in response........so according to this ayat of quran.....we all muslims respect the great and one of the oldest religion of the world , hinduism.......yes accepting it or not is a different thing but we respect this religion...the gods and personalities in it like Karishna, Hanuman , argun etc etc..... as given in quran that do not sa a bad word to there gods.....