Iran leader: Holocaust a 'myth'

[Das_Reich]

Re: Iran leader: Holocaust a ‘myth’

@antiobl

Hey man! I know the history of Afghanistan. So please don’t try to justify one ethnic cleansing with another brutal suppression.

I am sure you do, but the point I am trying to make is that if we commemorate one atrocity or warcrime as a holocaust lets not forget the other ones.
If jews were the victims of facsism in WWII so were millions of germans who were ethinically cleasned from eastern europe(esp.Czech and poland ) in 1945.
German PoWs were kept till 1955 in camps in total violation of all international law

This dosent mean that holocaust was justified but also remember these victims they were just as innocent as many jews.

[Reza_Pahlavi]

Re: Iran leader: Holocaust a ‘myth’

antiobl is comparing the the Jews to Imam Khomeini and the Taliban in the same breath. but cannot answer why they (the Jews) are the only people in the world who demand laws to protect their myths about the holocaust?

[Ma_Mooli]

Re: Iran leader: Holocaust a ‘myth’

Laws or No laws, Shia Muslims have indeed forced their opinions when possible. Sunnis in Iran are already a persecuted minority. Why? Because they do not fit in the Shia frame of law.

Do you have any evidence to back up your persecution claim? i dont see shia/sunnis killings going on in Iran.

How come Shia Muslims always send “good words” to Sunni Khalifas?

or

How come the implementation of Fiqah Jafriah in Pakistan became a violent struggle against Sunnis.

How and when was fiqh e jaffri implemented? Its always been there since pak was ever made. As for the violence, im sure you know the idea was to rid pak of shias, hence the persecution against them. If it was a struggle, it was for survival of shias in a sunni dominant country. And not the other way around.

Who urged the Quetta Shias to burn Police Stations immediately after revolution in Iran?

i dunno, but it sure wasnt Ayatullah khomeini.

Wasn’t Imam Khomayni trying to export his version of Islamic law to every place he could?

No he wasn’t. It was only for Iran where the masses approved of it..

The worst possible crime ever committed by anyone in recent history is holding American diplomats as hostages.

yeah…right. would that be because they were ‘american’ hostages?

i suggest you brush up on your ‘recent history’.

[antiobl]

Re: Iran leader: Holocaust a ‘myth’

@Ma Mooli

… As for the violence, im sure you know the idea was to rid pak of shias, hence the persecution against them. If it was a struggle, it was for survival of shias in a sunni dominant country. …

Agreed! In post-Khomaini period, life for Shia minority has been really difficult in Pakistan. My blood boils with anger and frustration when I think about 72 Shia Doctors murdered in Karachi a couple of years ago.

However Ma Mooli, and Reza! Persecution of Shias in Pakistan at the moment should make them more sensitive to the precarious situation with similar minorities in other parts of the world.

I expect that today’s Pakistani-Shias would stand up for Ahmadis in Pakistan, or Jewish people in Europe, America, the Middle East, or Sunnis in Iran.

Won’t you agree?

@Ma Mooli

…yeah…right. would that be because they were ‘american’ hostages? :rolleyes :

No they were just diplomats who happened to be Americans. It was wrong then and it is wrong now.

It is also wrong to physically abuse Bharati diplomats in Pakistan. If you don’t like a diplomat, hey just ask him to leave. Capturing, torturing, or holding them hostages is utterly wrong in the eyes of modern laws, as well as in the eyes of our Messenger ‘saw’.

Best regards