India 'diverts funds for poor to pay for Commonwealth games'

Billions of rupees of development funds diverted from their intended purpose, and an estimated 140,000 poor people evicted from their homes in an effort to show off how much India is “shining.” Frankly, this attitude is why, despite all of its recent economic successes, (percentagewise) India still has significantly more starving children than Somalia and Ethiopia and many other of the world’s most impoverished and underdeveloped nations.


Tens of millions of dollars have been diverted in India from schemes to fight poverty and used to fund Delhi’s Commonwealth Games, a report says.

The Housing and Land Rights Network pressure group says its report is based on official documents obtained under India’s right to information act.

The group says there should be an independent inquiry into how this was allowed to happen.

Government officials in Delhi say they are looking into the allegations.

‘Clear evidence’
This report is a damning indictment of the way the Commonwealth Games have been financed and planned by the central and state governments.

It says tens of millions of dollars have been diverted from funds which are supposed to help raise underprivileged low caste communities out of poverty.

The report also says spending on the Games has spiralled out of control: expenditure on sports infrastructure alone is more than 2,000% of the initial projected budget.

**In addition, more than 100,000 poor families have already been evicted due to projects connected with the Games, and up to 40,000 families are likely to be displaced before the Games begin in October, the document says.
**
The report’s author, Miloon Kothari, a former UN human rights rapporteur, told the BBC that the evidence was clear.

The determination, he said, to portray Delhi as a world-class city and an international sports destination, had led the government to lose sight of its legal and moral commitments to its people.

Re: India 'diverts funds for poor to pay for Commonwealth games'

lol...

This elitist arrogance of India never ceases to surprise me. Its the same attitude which produces images of towering office buildings, but absolutely no coverage of the sprawling ghetto just next door...

Re: India 'diverts funds for poor to pay for Commonwealth games'

**100,000 poor families evicted!

**Wow... Imagine that happening in the US...

Don't make no difference, India don't have funds to feed its starving to death let alone hungry.

Re: India 'diverts funds for poor to pay for Commonwealth games'

i am really thankful to the people of pakistan who think and worry for india so much...even by surpassing their own fiasco in all matters...

Re: India 'diverts funds for poor to pay for Commonwealth games'

i believe the person who started this thread is from srinagar, and last time I checked that was not a part of Pakistan, or did I miss some news this afternoon?

You are welcome. Just remember we have a whole forum dedicated to 'our own fiasco' but we do need to cater for a big neighboring country with which we share our language, culture and mutual 'love'.

Planning and constructing commonwealth games related infrastructure has met with one disaster after another, one scandal after another, but atleast India is going to host them and it would benefit the country a lot in coming years.

Actually, this thread was started by someone from Indian occupied Kashmir. Someone the Indians claim is in fact, an Indian.

Still. regardless of who started this thread, we Pakistanis arent the ones making all kinds of tall claims, its Indians that do that. So whats wrong with reminding you every now and then? Sometimes a dose of reality is a good thing.

Re: India 'diverts funds for poor to pay for Commonwealth games'

Amazing India... ! or was it Incredible India

Re: India 'diverts funds for poor to pay for Commonwealth games'

instead of competing with us in progress, scientific gains...they compete with us in corrupton and poverty....

i can understand their grievances....

^ Progress & Scientifc Gains.. wow!!!

Is actually shinning India

That's ironic, coming from an Indian who spends his free time trolling a Pakistani forum for no other purpose than to criticize Pakistan & Muslims.

Who said anyone's competing?

I think the point is to demonstrate to Indians that they arent yet anywhere near the shining India they claim, lest they become complacent.

As well as an example for other developing countries, including Pakistan, of how not to tackle poverty and corruption...

Who are you talking to by the way? :hehe:

Re: India 'diverts funds for poor to pay for Commonwealth games'

i will not say..that truth hurts...

let these people tell us some role model we can follow.....out of so many islamic states first of all, and then rest of the world from japan to states via europe........

i want to know if they have some ideal in mind...do they have respect for any single country in the world to follow....

Im sure many countries have many good examples to offer... But as far as tackling poverty and corruption, India is the least likely candidate worth emulating.

Re: India 'diverts funds for poor to pay for Commonwealth games'

there are over 1.1 billion people in India, even after 50 years from now there are going to be poor in India, there is no parallel, it is not as if though India has 60 crores of people and most of them are poor, India's population density is 5 times of Pakistan and her wealth is 50 times of Pakistan, if any one had followed India from its Independence the problems that she faced is more than 100 times of Pakistan ever would face, today those problems are less than 5 % of what it was in the beginning, only problem we face today is of managing a huge population and we are managing it ok.

China has more than 1.3 billion people; of them 16% live under the international poverty line ($1.25 US/day); childhood starvation rate is about 7%. In contrast, 42% of India lives under the international poverty line and almost 50% of Indian children are starving.

I agree, there always will be poor people in India, just as there always will be poor people in the US and Switzerland. The issue here is that, despite all of its recent economic successes, India remains by and large a wretchedly poor nation, and (as demonstrated above) seems more interested in showing off a false display of economic well-being than in actually improving the lot of its impoverished people.

I see you're just making things up now.
India population density - 360/km2
Pakistan population density - 211/km2
Not sure why it's relevant, but India's population density is not even close to double Pakistan's, let alone being "5 times" higher.

As for GDP (which is what I assume you mean by "wealth"), India's GDP is roughly 6.5 times higher than Pakistan's, which is approximately commiserate with the size of its population. Which is why the nominal per capita GDP in India $1,031 to Pakistan's $1,017 (according to the IMF) or $900 to Pakistan's $1,000 (according to the CIA).

It's also important to note that while both nations are fairly similar in terms of per capita GDP, Pakistan actually does better in terms of basic poverty markers - which is to say that whatever wealth there is in Pakistan is marginally more equitably distributed.
Population below international poverty line - 42% in India vs 23% in Pakistan
Childhood starvation rates - 48% India vs 38% Pakistan
Population with access to proper sanitation/sewers - 28% India vs 58% Pakistan
etc.

Re: India 'diverts funds for poor to pay for Commonwealth games'

Now that you are comparing India and Pakistan, we should realize that it is INDIA that is hosting commonwealth games and not Pakistan. They must be doing something better.