In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

“To be a Sufi is to clear your heart of everything but God,” he explained. “The Islam we were taught here is like a body without a soul. Sufism is the soul. It’s not an alternative religion – it can contain all Muslims.”
This is a small hope for the future of our faith…

In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism
Mystical Sect of Islam Finds Its Voice in More Tolerant Post-9/11 Era

By Faiza Saleh Ambah
Special to The Washington Post
Tuesday, May 2, 2006; A13

JIDDAH, Saudi Arabia – A hush came over the crowd as the young man sitting cross-legged on the floor picked up the microphone and sang, a cappella, a poem about Islam’s prophet Muhammad. His eyes shut tight, his head covered by an orange-and-white turban, he crooned with barely contained ardor of how the world rejoiced and lights filled the skies the day the prophet was born.

The men attending the mawlid – a celebration of the birth and life of Muhammad – sat on colorful rugs, rocking gently back and forth, while the women, on the upper floor watching via a large projection screen, passed around boxes of tissues and wiped tears from their eyes.

The centuries-old mawlid, a mainstay of the more spiritual and often mystic Sufi Islam, was until recently viewed as heretical and banned by Saudi Arabia’s official religious establishment, the ultraconservative Wahhabis. But a new atmosphere of increased religious tolerance has spurred a resurgence of Sufism and brought the once-underground Sufis and their rituals out in the open.

Analysts and some Sufis partly credit reaction to the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks in the United States for the atmosphere that has made the changes possible. When it was discovered that 15 of the 19 hijackers were Saudi, the kingdom’s strict Wahhabi doctrine – which had banned all other sects and schools of thought – came under intense scrutiny from inside and outside the country. The newfound tolerance Sufis have come to enjoy is perhaps one of the most concrete outcomes of that shift.

“This is one of the blessings of September 11. It put the brakes on the [Wahhabi] practice of takfir , excommunicating everyone who didn’t exactly follow their creed,” said Sayed Habib Adnan, a 33-year-old Sufi teacher. The government “realized that maybe enforcing one religious belief over all others was not such a good idea.”

When Adnan moved to Saudi Arabia from his native Yemen four years ago, Sufi gatherings were often clandestine, sometimes held in orchards outside the city, or in basements and without microphones, for fear of drawing attention. “I couldn’t wear this,” he said, pointing to his turban. “Or this,” he said, pulling at his white cotton overcoat. “Or I would be branded a Sufi. You couldn’t even say the word ‘Sufi.’ It was something underground, dangerous, like talking about drugs.”

Sufis here say they are not a separate sect or followers of a separate religion, but adherents to a way of life based on the Muslim concept of ihsan . Muhammad explained ihsan to the angel Gabriel as “worshiping God as if you see Him. Because if you don’t see Him, He sees you.” Another Sufi characteristic is a strong belief in the power of blessings from the prophet, his close relatives and his companions.

Sufism had previously been predominant in Hejaz, the western region of Saudi Arabia, which includes Muhammad’s birthplace, Mecca; Medina, where he is buried; and the Red Sea port city of Jiddah. Muslims prayed often at shrines where the prophet’s daughter Fatima, his wife Khadija and his companions were buried. Mawlids were public affairs with entire cities decked out in lights, and parades and festivities commemorating the prophet’s birthday and his ascension to Jerusalem.

When the al-Saud family that would later come to rule Saudi Arabia took over Hejaz in the 1920s, the Wahhabis banned mawlids as a form of heresy and destroyed the historic shrines of Khadija, Fatima and the prophet’s companions, fearing they would lead to idolatry and polytheism.

Wahhabis, crucial allies in the Saud conquest of the disparate regions that became Saudi Arabia in 1932, were awarded control of religious affairs.

Discrimination against Sufis, among others, intensified after armed Wahhabi extremists took over Mecca’s Grand Mosque in 1979, demanding that a more puritanical form of Islam be applied in the country. Though the government quelled the uprising and executed its leaders, authorities were shaken by the incident, and lest other Wahhabis defy them, they allowed them more rein.

Soon after, extremist clerics issued a religious edict, or fatwa, declaring Sufi’s spiritual leader, Muhammad Alawi Malki, a nonbeliever. He was removed from his teaching position, banned from giving lessons at the Grand Mosque, where both his father and grandfather had taught, and interrogated by the religious police and the Interior Ministry. After Malki was later attacked by a throng of radicals incensed at his presence in the mosque, he could pray there only under armed guard.

Meanwhile, thousands of cassettes and booklets circulated calling Sufis “grave-lovers” and dangerous infidels who had to be stopped before they made a comeback. Their salons were raided, and those caught with Sufi literature were often arrested or jailed.

The tide finally turned in 2003, with the new atmosphere that took hold following the Sept. 11 attacks, when the future King Abdullah, then the crown prince, held a series of meetings to acknowledge the country’s diverse sects and schools of thought. One of the guests was Sufi leader Malki. When he died the following year, Abdullah and the powerful defense and interior ministers attended his funeral. The rehabilitation of his legacy was almost complete.

“We were then upgraded from infidels, to people who are ignorant and practicing their religion wrong,” said Wasif Kabli, a 59-year-old businessman.

But many Sufis complain that despite outward appearances, Wahhabis continue to destroy shrines in and around their holy places, their salons continue to be raided and their literature is still banned.

Wahhabis and Sufis view Islam from opposite directions. To Wahhabis, who emerged from the kingdom’s stark, harsh desert, a believer’s relationship can be only directly with God. To them, Sufis’ celebrations of the prophet’s life smack of idolatry, and supplications to him, his relatives and companions appear to replace or bypass the link with God.

Sufis answer that the prophet celebrated his own birthday by fasting on Mondays, that he himself offered to intervene with God on behalf of Muslims and that he could often be found in the evenings at the grave sites of his wives and companions.

Last month, on the occasion of the prophet’s birthday, a crowd of more than 1,000 gathered to celebrate at a private residence. Sufi books, cassettes and DVDs were selling out in one corner of the large garden where the event was held. Adnan, the Sufi teacher, was one of four speakers who addressed the crowd. He asked: Why are we Sufis always on the defensive? “Nobody asks [soccer] fans for religious proof that sanctifies their gatherings at the stadium because of their devotion to their team,” he said. “How come we are always asked for an explanation of our devotion to our beloved prophet?”

Muhammad Jastaniya, a 20-year-old economics major and part of a new wave of young Saudis who have embraced Sufism, said what drew him was the focus on God.

On a recent moonlit evening, Jastaniya sipped sugary mint tea with his friends on rugs spread on the rooftop of a Zawiya, or lodge where Sufis go to meditate, chant or sit in on lessons. The words ‘God’ and ‘Muhammad’ were written in green neon lights, and Islam’s 99 names for God were stenciled in black paint around the wall. “To be a Sufi is to clear your heart of everything but God,” he explained. “The Islam we were taught here is like a body without a soul. Sufism is the soul. It’s not an alternative religion – it can contain all Muslims.”

That thought seems to be taking hold, even in faraway corners.

Salman al-Odah, the country’s most popular puritanical cleric, who was jailed in the 1990s for opposing the presence of U.S. troops in the kingdom, accepted an invitation to visit Sufi cleric Abdallah Fadaaq’s mawlid and lesson last week. The scene at Fadaaq’s house was an obvious sign of conciliation.

Al-Odah sat with his hands neatly folded in his lap, wearing a red-and-white checkered headdress and clear wraparound glasses and sporting the short scraggly beard that indicates a conservative. Fadaaq, who at 39 is emerging as the new symbol of Hejazi Sufism, wore the white turban, the white overcoat and shawl typical of Sufis, wooden prayer beads resting on his lap. “It’s true that there are differences between the way people practice their faith in this country, and this is an indication that people are using their minds and thinking, which is a good thing,” Fadaaq said. “But what we should concentrate on are the expanses that bring us together, like the prophet. We must take advantage of what we have in common.”

© 2006 The Washington Post Company
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/05/01/AR2006050101380_pf.html

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

The writer of this article is a cheap sellout...

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

Would you consider Imam al-Ghazali a cheap sell-out?

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

sooner or later, truth has to prevail .

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

Here’s a Kleenex, please dry your tears.

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

Alhumdulillah.

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

There are several reasons for resurgence of sufism not only in KSA but also in other parts of the world.

One: Wahabism like one of my friend describes, acted like a person who thought of cleaning his house of all trash, he did it, but he did not decorate it at all. He left it clean but plain.

Second: Sufi version is diverse, extremely diverse, and has no political agenda, this is more acceptable to world. Even the Rand corporation has recomended that sufi version of Islam be promoted among muslims.

Third: Because of its diversity, many different people can find choose what they like in Sufism. It has room for people who practice the islamic law to those who don't.

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

Lajjo what parts of the article do you think indicate the author's selling out? I think its pretty accurate, what parts are misleading, please specify.

Icono sunnies often say that in time of doubt stick to the majority creed. Given what you say, do you feel that would apply here?

As for sufism being friendly to the west, remember that Saudi Arabia, a very very wahabi country in policy until a couple of years, and still dominantly wahabi in policy today, is a very close ally of Amreeka.

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

I dont know what sunnis you hang around with, but there is no such rule as that. Infact a well known sahih hadeeth proves that rule to be wrong. The Prophet pedicted 73 sects in Islam and only one would go to heaven, so naturally that saved sect is a minority amongst those 73 sects. The majority would always go with the flow, with the fitan of the times..and being part of the majority would lead him/her to destruction.

Saudi Arabia is just like any other country...distorting Allah's Laws to please their Masters (U.S. Government) and to serve their own selfish purposes.

You wanna know how much of a wahhabi Saudi Govt. is, why dont you go check out Saudi Jails. They are packed with Wahaabi scholars.

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

Sharaabi, The Holy Prophet (saws) never said that of those 73 sects, that the rest except one would spend eternity in the hellfire.

Also in reference to those 73 sects, it is the one group that is the largest group and is not a minority, that is the saved sect. If we were to say that that one saved sect is a minority, then we are saying that most of the Muslims in the world would be spending some time in the hellfire? Naudhubillah, how can one discern such a thing?

Finally in reference to those sects, they are not differing in the belief, all believe in La ilaha il-Allah Muhammad ar-Rasul-lillah. A sect which does not posess the belief in the Kalimah, are not considered Muslims. Therefore we cannot say that the majority of Muslims naudhubillah are astray...groups such as the Qadiani's, Druze, etc., are not included amongst those sects because they have changed their Aqidah (belief).

So Wahhabi Government is jailing their Wahhabi scholars? Sounds like progress to me.

I think you mean that Wahhabi government is jailing Salafi scholars because the scholars belonging to the Salafite sect want to overthrow the Saudi regime. Remember the Imam leading the prayers in Makka Mukarramah a few years back when he started calling upon the destruction of America and that attacks be launched against them, in his concluding du'a?

Either way, the salafiyya still branched out from Wahhabiya...

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

^ Yes, those 73 sects that the Prophet Muhammad (sas) talked about are from within the folds of Islam and yes they do believe in the declaration of faith. They will not be doomed to Hell fire for ever, but will spend some portion of time in Hell and they will eventually go to heaven.

The Saved sect, however, goes directly to Heaven without any punishment.

I dont see how that one sect out of 73 sects comprises the majority of Muslims, and how the majority of Muslims will be able to make it to Heaven, unpunished...when Muslims are engulfed in sins, and when Quran itself says...that every human being shall visit hell fire.

Sheikh Mohammad Al Mohaisny, may Allah protect him and may Allah have mercy on him, he got released a little while ago.

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

http://www.usc.edu/dept/MSA/fundamentals/hadithsunnah/muslim/020.smt.html#020.4553

I understand that wahabies take great pains to discredit the notion of the majority being right (ironically a lot like shias) but most regular sunni ulema place great emphasis on being the ahlus sunnah wal jamaah, where they take jamaah to be the majority.

Coming to your statement that

Explain this reasoning to me. In the above Sahih Hadis, the Prophet recommends the sahabi to stick to the main body of Muslims in a time of doubt. You say that the majority would “always” go with the fitan of the times, and being with the majority would lead to destruction.

Even if your claim that the majority is always with the fitan of the times is admitted and we dont try to reconcile that with the Prophetic advice to stick with the majority, how is that a proof! Within 73 sects, unless there is a huge coincidence one will always be the majority, and it is your opinion that that particular segment would always be with the fitan of the times.

Irani jails have had irani scholars including those of the revolution. That does not mean that the policy of iran is shia influenced, much like the policy of Saudi Arab is wahabi influenced, evidence of which you can find in the mutawwas and the destruction of shrines and that the officially designated clerics espouse salafi beliefs. Sure theres a group of salafies that dont like Saudi Arabian govt, but thats a seperate issue.

The govt of Saudi Arab has been extremely cooperative with the US for years and has held strict wahabi policy until a couple of years ago where they loosened just a little. The argument of iconoclast was that Sufi Islam would be favourable to amreeka. I countered that with an example of a very cooperative ally to america with wahabi clerical backing.

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

Prophet celebrating his birthday fasting on Mondays ???!!!?? :nono4:

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

He should have been kept in their longer for making such irresponsible statements. We are not supposed to be made into sheep being sent for a slaughter. Constructive combat is what should be considered, not screaming and crying for terror to be sent upon others so that some Muslims can be incited to do something stupid.

You're forgetting the intercession of the Prophet for his Ummah on the day of Judgement.

Like the brother just said, the majority is the one that sticks to the Jama'ah. It is unthinkable to suggest that Rasul-Allah's (saws) original message has turned into a minority and is a small group amongst 73 sects of Islam, naudhubillah.

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

When a Wahabbi declares a grave worshipper as a mushrik, it is of no concern to the non-believer what a Mushrik is, what a Muslim is or what Shirk is…It is between the sects that scholars of various schools of thought have interpreted Islam…

When a Muslim who comes out and demonizes a certan sect of Islam as being such and such in an open ed editorial of a leadiong newspaper, I find that it’s nothing more than selling a stereotype…

What does the Kafir need to know about what a Sufi or a Wahabbi is? They need to know what is Islam…So when a Sufi goes upon a soapbox and venerates his beliefs while ridiculing other beliefs, I consider it selling out…

The proper way to judge what is correct and not is to have scholars and learned men of understanding of both sects to have a dialogue…Printing derogatory or articles that defame or malign a sect is nothing more than selling out…

And if Wahabbism was the culprit, there wouldn’t be as many Wahabbi scholars in Saudi jails as there are today…I had a link where a scholar who was released from such a prison wrote the tortures they had to endure at the hands of the KSA authority…Because it is Wahabbism which is vehemently opposed to the kingship and many scholars have spoken out against it…As a result they have been thrown in torure chambers…

So this lady is a sellout…She prints what the public would like to hear…

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

Yes…They should celebrate Milad by having rock n roll Qawwals headbang the night away…:AllahHuAllahHuAllahHu:

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

I dunno, its too much for me to say. I have been a sufi for 4-5 years, i have been wahabi and i was born in a Hanafi,Deobandi family. So i have seen them all, and all have positive and negative points. I generally feel that majority ARE right, and in Pakistan, majority are Hanafi, Deobandis. However, i wonder how would u put this aaya in the context of Hadeeth that u have qouted.

5:100 Say: “Not equal are things that are bad and things that are good, even though the abundance of the bad may dazzle thee; so fear Allah, O ye that understand; that (so) ye may prosper.”

I do not say that Sufis are friendly to west. However, sufis have no political agenda, atleast an overwhelming majority of them, hence they are more ‘acceptable’ to west. I don’t think its the other way round.

And at different times in different places, various groups have enjoyed majority. Iran had majority of sunnis couple of centuries ago, but not anymore. KSA itself had majority of sufis. Till a few years ago, it appeared that wahabis will be the majority group among Muslims. The resources and money available to them thru Saudis, and aggressive preaching made lot of followers in west. Almost all converts had a wahabi aqeedah. Afghanistan and central asia which were traditionally Hanafi also saw lot of wahabi followers. However 2 things have turned the tables on Wahabis. The post 9/11 crackdown is one, there support declined among western muslims. Second was unrelentless attacks on other aqeedah like hanafis etc, which in retalliation turned against them.

We are alos now seeing a resugence of shiaism. Having remained dormant for centuries they had worked a lot among their own creed to keep them steadfast on their aqaid. Now that they have two states in which they enjoy majority that is Iraq and Iran, they too are putting up a fight to gain more followers among muslims.

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

  • Book 006, Number 2603: * Abu Qatada al-Ansari (Allah be pleased with him) reported that the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) was asked about his fasting. The Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) felt annoyed. Thereupon ‘Umar (Allah be pleased with him) said: We are pleased with Allah as the Lord, with Islam as our Code of Life, with Muhammad as the Messenger and with our pledge (to you for willing and cheerful submission) as a (sacred) commitment. He was then asked about perpetual fasting, whereupon he said: He neither fasted nor did he break it, or he did not fast and he did not break it. He was then asked about fasting for two days and breaking one day. He (the Holy Prophet) said: And who has strength enough to do it? He was asked about fasting for a day and breaking for two days, whereupon he said: May Allah bestow upon us strength to do it. He was then asked about fasting for a day and breaking on the other, whereupon he said: That is the fasting of my brother David (peace be upon him).****** He was then asked about fasting on Monday, whereupon he said: It was the day on which I was born.** on which I was commissioned with prophethood or revelation was sent to me, (and he further) said: Three days’ fasting every month and of the whole of Ramadan every year is a perpetual fast. He was asked about fasting on the day of 'Arafa (9th of Dhu’I-Hijja), whereupon he said: It expiates the sins of the preceding year and the coming year. He was asked about fasting on the day of 'Ashura (10th of Muharram), whereupon be said: It expiates the sins of the preceding year. (Imam Muslim said that in this hadith there is a) narration of Imam Shu’ba that he was asked about fasting on Monday and Thursday, but we (Imam Muslim) did not mention Thursday for we found it as an error (in reporting).

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

sufi approach is the way forward, there are various schools of sufis as well. Somehow people like to paint sufis as grave worshippinh doped up hippies, which is about as true as one can say all muslims are terrorists. For anyone interested in looking at a logical approach to sufism, I highly encourage reading up on the naqshbandi school of thought. If you are in Chicago U can visit the naqshbandi-haqqani center as well.

Re: In Saudi Arabia, a Resurgence of Sufism

^ mashallah, now thats what i call advice :rolleyes: