Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

All I know about Imran is that he is an opposition leader and has taken it upon himself to oppose everything the government does. Other than that there have been no notable achievements during his five years in the parliament. What I found most disappointing was his absence from parliamentary sessions and when questioned he replied that it is a futile exercise (not verbatim).

Imran was a great cricketer, a sharp cricketing brain who led Pakistan cricket to its pinnacle, the World cup. He then became a philanthropist and used his cricket fame, in a country that worships its cricket heros, to collect donations and build a modern cancer hospital in Lahore. This by no means was an easy task and Imran devoted his personal time, effort and I can easily assume his personal money for this dream to come true. What started out as a personal promise at the death of his mother turned out to be a major platform benefiting millions of poor Pakistanis who cant dream of affording such an expensive treatment let alone the kind of modern treatment SKMH provides. This however was not just Imran’s sole accomplishment. The entire nation supported him in this cause and even people earning less than a 100 rupees a day gave 10 rupiah per month towards the cause. The entire Pakistani team, television and film artists at the time attended the charity shows and collected donations. It was a national campaign and the entire nation should be proud of the accomplishment of SKMH dream and Imran in particular for leading the effort.

Imran then tried to cash in on the fame and turned to Pakistani politics. I do not question Imran’s sincerity, just like I don’t question Musharraf’s, towards making Pakistan a better country. He is amongst a select few Pakistani politicians who are not corrupt financially, although one can probably not prove any financial corruptness against any Pakistani politician, BB and NS being prime examples.

It has all been downhill since. Imran has turned more confusing with every passing year. What does he stand for? What does he want to change and how does he want to change it?

Imran wants to bring about change by changing laws and changing policies. What he is yet to realize is that laws and policies are all in place, it is the implementation that is lacking in Pakistan. I have read the manifesto of PTI and it is gives you no insight into how change shall be brought about.

Imran lost his first elections. I am not sure if he ever claimed rigging to be the reason, but it was generally accepted by public and although I was personally involved with the election campaign (on a very small level), I don’t remember anyone questioning the results. The tide was anti PPP and all votes, even people campaigning for Imran, voted for Nawaz Sharif just to keep BB out.
Khan Saab, made it to the assemblies in his second attempt by winning the seat in Mianwali, which is quite ironic. Considering that he stands against the typical Pakistani politics of biradari and personalities being bigger than the cause, he had to turn to his ancestral town, a place that was never his residence, to send him to the parliament.

Musharraff came to power promising the country that he will get rid of corrupt politicians and to achieve that he turned towards a person who was known nationally, was smart and presentable, said all the things Musharraff said and was not knowingly corrupt. Imran had the opportunity of a life time to make a difference, but it was probably the clash of two strong personalities that the set-up failed to materialize. Musharraf wanted more control, so did Imran. If Imran had been a politician, he would have taken up the opportunity and tried to work on the General from with-in. It is a shame as probably Pakistan was the loser.

As years passed, the fog around Imran Khan’s objectives only increased. Although he was un-willing to sit with the general, who at the time was supported by the majority, he sat with everyone else that he had opposed in the past.

Imran’s love affair with Jamat-e-Islami also makes a lot of Pakistanis skeptics of him. If Pakistanis wanted religious parties to rule them they would have had elected them in the countless elections that have been held.

PTI was a brain child of retired general Gul Hameed Bhatti, ex-ISI chief, the architect of Taliban movement and the brains behind the struggle in Afghanistan against Russia. So does that mean Imran supports organizations like Al-Qaeda?

Is he a moderate of a fundamentalist?

It has been 11 years since the inception of PTI, unfortunately it has yet to fill in its organizational posts at the national level. If Imran can’t even name his party organizers how does one expect him to name a cabinet, if let’s assume he becomes prime minister tomorrow?

His economic policies are no more than deewanay ki baR, because reality is far different.

Why is it that he has not been able to attract any person of political stature to his party or promote anyone from the current members of his party at the National level?

How does he want to change the country’s destiny with his radical views when he doesn’t even have a team? Has he forgotten that winning the world cup and making Shaukat Khanum Hospital were team efforts?

In the last year Imran has just become anti Musharraff, and he doesnt care who he join hands with and how conflicting it is with what he says. How is he different from Musharraff if he is willing to sit with BB and NS? How is that any different from Musharraff having an alliance of convinience with PMLQ or PPP?

[FONT=‘Times New Roman’]Unfortunately he is going to waste his potential because of his tremendous ego. Asghar Khan anyone?

2 Likes

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

Wow, he has been in politics for 10 years. Oh well, atleast now, after all these years, he has decided pilitics is not for him and not taking part in elections.

Just aswell. He may have lost his party's only seat.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

[quote]
PTI was a brain child of retired general Gul Hameed Bhatti, ex-ISI chief, the architect of Taliban movement and the brains behind the struggle in Afghanistan against Russia. So does that mean Imran supports organizations like Al-Qaeda?
[/quote]

Yep, and now Imran and Hameed Gul, along with Qazi another Taliban-lover are leaders of the rump APDM.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

So one single brain made Taliban exist. From one day to another. It's sounds as frigging as Bush claims OBL is the ony one behind 911.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

all I will commenyt on is on the lack of a cohesive organized political entity which has created a space for itself has shown the nation a real agenda and steps it would take to reach it.

The big question is...would PTI continue to exist if Imran left it today? I doubt it.

real political parties like PPP would continue to exist because as much as I dislike PPP for keeping latched on to BB, the party can carry on without her, and continue to be successful .

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

One of the best Analysis of Imran & his politics.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

he just came in politics to damage his reuptation which he did very well.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

Well written, yet the gullible still want him to be Amir-ul-Momineen of Pakistan/Talibanistan.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

I didn't read all of this post but found this 'interesting'. Hameed Gul retired long time ago, the foundation of Taliban/Alkeyda is supposed to be on shoulders of Akthar Abdul Rehman (Afghan resistance), Naseerullah Babar (Afghan "restructuring" aka Taliban). I don't see the link of PTI with Taliban/Alkeyda via Hameed Gul, rather his fondness of MMA/JI (probably because the majority of people in his area have supported these parties as of late (last elections?)

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

Yes indeed. Well written.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

He actively trained jihadis when he was in the ISI and obviously kept in touch when he was out of the ISI as a personal passion.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

anyways this si about Imran and not hameed teh psycho gul.

Imran needs better people around him, he needs to find some good deputies who can carry out his vision by finding more people, for doing the detailed ground work necessary to have a real ideological partyu with real solutions.

I dont know if all the people who support Imran just talk about it or are actually investing time and effort, blood sweat and tears for PTI.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

I wrote this after seeing the support Imran gets on this board in general and in the next PM thread in particular. Although GS is no measure of how the country feels about individuals in Pakistani politics, it does surprise me that relatively more educated people who are living in the west and in their posts do complain the ills of Pakistani politics revolving around individuals, turn around and do exactly that. The Imran supporters on this board display the same coflicting logic Imran Khan's politics displays.

I would have liked the Imran supporters to come here and debate his attributes and accomplishments with me. They are in every other thread but for some reason avoided mine.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

Captain1, maybe architect was not the right word or may be it was, i wont go into details of that. Akhtar abdur-rehman's spearheaded the Mujahedeen revolution against the Russians, Taliban became a movement after russians left and there was a lot of infighting in afghanistan between different mujahideen groups.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

Well, I don't really support Imran Khan (or any other politician for that matter), but he has principles, and thats the reason why educated people support him. Everyone else has been tried and tested, and all of them are corrupt to the core, but I don't see Imran or his party getting anywhere in politics. He might as well say good bye to politics, and start doing something else...charity work maybe? He is good at that.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

Define corruption please because to claim the everyone else is corrupt your criteria has to be very wide.

Imran's principles are a good thing but he is not the only one with principles. Also what good does that do to Pakistan and 160 million Pakistanis? I will not appoint the maulvi sahab of the masjid I go to as the CEO in my company just because of his good principles. Imran's politics lacks practicality, it is very easy to sit on the sidelines and criticize everything, it is very difficult to put yourself in other person's shoes. Imran's parlimentary career (all 5 years) has just been that of a trouble maker. He has just developed a confrontational attitude where as what was needed from him was positive criticism and solutions. Give Pakistanis some credit, they are as smart any anyother nation in the world (although my bias says they are the smartest, this is addressed to someone in particular and not PA posters, you know who you are ;) ).

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

No, not really. Mushrrafs entire cabinet was/is made up thugs, thieves and murderers. That is not very broad definition. Its there for all to see. Remember Mushrraf kicked out NS promising clean govt, and turned around and hired the same people he kicked out?

[quote]
Imran's parlimentary career (all 5 years) has just been that of a trouble maker.
[/quote]

I don't live in his parliamentary constituency, but you should go and see the work he has done for the people he was representing. From what I heard its pretty impressive.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

imran's pursuit of a utopian philosophy is what gets me paranoid. someone should tell him that his egotistic nature combined with his half-baked notions of sufism is a recipe for disaster. maybe him not getting to a position of power is a blessing for pakistan.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

Shamraz, my friend, just saying everyone is a thug will not give you a verdict against them in any court in the world. BB, Zardari and Nawaz were all tried for corruption but nothing was proved. Even then Musharraff did not bring those thugs to the parliament, you and I did. Musharraff just sided with the biggest alliance of thugs.

Please do not limit Imran's accountability to that of the city Nazim's role, he is in the parliament not the head of Mianwali's muncipal council.

Re: Imran Khan; Over a Decade in Politics, Still an Enigma

No, you should not take my words for it. BTW, are you saying MQM, Choudrays, and rest of the Mushrraf allies are not corrupt? As for courts, it doesn't matter. Courts work for those in power, not for little guy, and we know how much respect Mushrraf has for the judiciary. That is a different story all together.

[quote]
BB, Zardari and Nawaz were all tried for corruption but nothing was proved. Even then Musharraff did not bring those thugs to the parliament, you and I did. Musharraff just sided with the biggest alliance of thugs.
[/quote]

In that case why did government spent billions of rupees chasing BB & Zardari all over Europe on corruption cases for 8 years, and thn Mushrraf turned around and issued NRO? BTW, thanks for admitting that Mushrraf allies are thugs. As saying goes, you're as good as the company you keep.

[quote]
Please do not limit Imran's accountability to that of the city Nazim's role, he is in the parliament not the head of Mianwali's muncipal council.
[/QUOTE]

The concept of parliamentary democracy is that MPs are elected to represent locals on national level. They get millions of rupees per year for development of their constituencies. They are suppose to use that money to build roads, schools, hospitals, etc.