i'm still confused regarding namaz-e-tarawee

Society Religion & Philosophy
1

regardless of wats been said on this issue last week or b/f i still don’t get it!

just yes or no answers plz

  1. iz it a sin to miss namaz-e-taravee deliberately (intentionally)?

a) wat is the punishment if so?

  1. is it true dat if one doesn’t pray namaz-e-tarave his/her’s following days rooza isn’t accepted (its mukrooh)?
2

Re: i'm still confused regarding namaz-e-tarawee

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by #let uz chat#: *
**just yes or no answers plz

1) iz it a sin to miss namaz-e-taravee deliberately (intentionally)?

a) wat is the punishment if so?

2) is it true dat if one doesn't pray namaz-e-tarave his/her's following days rooza isn't accepted (its mukrooh)?
[/QUOTE]
**

  1. i don't think so - because it is sunnah not obligatory
  2. If i am right about the above, then there would be no punishment
  3. i don't think so

Allah knows best.

Of course it is highly recommended to perform taraweeh. It is not absolutely obligatory, however. Performing it is considered very meritorious, however; there is an ahadith from Muslim that states, "Whoever observes night prayer in Ramadan as an expression of his faith and to seek reward from Allah, his previous sins will be blotted out." Of course Allah knows best; i could be mistaken so please no one quote me on this. Someone more knowledgeable will come around to correct me if i am wrong. It's an act of great sawaab, so i think we should try our best not to miss it.

3

why dont u ask ur local imam? just go up to him n ask him..
im not sure on the answers myself ..otherwise wudv helped..

4

Re: i'm still confused regarding namaz-e-tarawee

1) iz it a sin to miss namaz-e-taravee deliberately (intentionally)?
NO....

a) wat is the punishment if so?
u get reward for praying it, there is no punishment for missing it....

2) is it true dat if one doesn't pray namaz-e-tarave his/her's following days rooza isn't accepted (its mukrooh)?
NO.... taraweeh has no effect on roza whatsoever....

5

Taraweeh is Bidah

Aslam-o-Alakum,

Taraweeh is Bidah, you dont have to pray this Namaz in congregation after isah' prayer in the month of Ramadan. It is not from the teachings of the Holy Prophet (PBUH). It was innovated after him.

You have to pray tahajjud prayer in the later part night in Ramazan and in other months.

[QUOTE]
there is an ahadith from Muslim that states, "Whoever observes night prayer in Ramadan as an expression of his faith and to seek reward from Allah, his previous sins will be blotted out."
[/QUOTE]

review this hadith..kindly

Correct me if i am wrong, at this address

[email protected]

6

Re: Taraweeh is Bidah

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by inuit: *
Aslam-o-Alakum,

Taraweeh is Bidah, you dont have to pray this Namaz in congregation after isah' prayer in the month of Ramadan. It is not from the teachings of the Holy Prophet (PBUH). It was innovated after him.

You have to pray tahajjud prayer in the later part night in Ramazan and in other months.

review this hadith..kindly

Correct me if i am wrong, at this address

[email protected]
[/QUOTE]

It will be nice if you also mentioned what fiqh's point of view it is.

7

[QUOTE]
1) iz it a sin to miss namaz-e-taravee deliberately (intentionally)?
[/QUOTE]

No

[QUOTE]
a) wat is the punishment if so?
[/QUOTE]

None

[QUOTE]
2) is it true dat if one doesn't pray namaz-e-tarave his/her's following days rooza isn't accepted (its mukrooh)?
[/QUOTE]

It is accepted

This is what I think, you might want to make sure with a scholar.

8

Taraweeh is a naffil. Just keep that in mind.

9

Asalam-o-Alakum Changez_like

This email is in response of your message posted at http://www.gupistan.com/forums regarding Taraweeh Prayer. Here is the message you posted.

My brother ! There is no need to mention any fiqah because it is in the Hadith. The same hadith, which is considered to be one of the basic hadith for Taraweeh Prayer. However in Fiqah-e-Jafferiya there is only Tahajjud Prayer in the month of Ramazan as well as other months. The following is the Hadith with its online link.

If you like, you can join a discussion on Taraweeh at http://dev.answering-ansar.org and click the topics “Topics for New Articles”.

However, Thanks for your interest and your questions that you asked in a nice manner.

Wasalam

[email protected]

10

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by inuit: *
Asalam-o-Alakum Changez_like
....
There is no need to mention any fiqah because it is in the Hadith. The same hadith, which is considered to be one of the basic hadith for Taraweeh Prayer. However in Fiqah-e-Jafferiya there is only Tahajjud Prayer in the month of Ramazan as well as other months. ...
[/QUOTE]

WoA,

Thanks for clarifying that. However, Prophet Mohammed PBUH did organize "Taraweeh" after Ishaa (Qiyam-ul-layl perhaps) during Ramadan, but he didn't do it on regular basis fearing that it might be made "Fard" which may prove to be tough for many.

11

Asalam-o-Alakum,

Thanks for the prompt reply.

[QUOTE]
Prophet Mohammed PBUH did organize "Taraweeh" after Ishaa (Qiyam-ul-layl perhaps) during Ramadan, but he didn't do it on regular basis fearing that it might be made "Fard" which may prove to be tough for many.
[/QUOTE]
It will be nice if you also mention the reference. However the hadith I mentioned above shows that Prophet Mohammed (PBUH) did NOT ORGANIZE "Taraweeh" AFTER ISHAA during the month of Ramadan as well as ANY other month.

People usually confuse Taraweeh prayer with Tahajjud prayer. However these are different prayers. “Fear that it might become Fard” is in fact not for Taraweeh, it is for Tahajjud Prayer.

Moreover the reason of “FEAR” was never given while the Taraweeh Prayer was being introduced (innovated). It was just called an Excellent Bidah’ as you read in the Hadith. Additionally the merits of Tahajjud prayer is described.

Taraweeh Prayer an Innovation in religion in views of Hazrat Umar

[QUOTE]
'Umar remarked, 'What an excellent Bid'a (i.e. innovation in religion) this is;
[/QUOTE]
Hazrat Umar Described the Merits of Tahajjud Prayer

[QUOTE]
but the prayer which they do not perform, but sleep at its time is better than the one they are offering.' He meant the prayer in the last part of the night. (In those days) people used to pray in the early part of the night."
[/QUOTE]

Thanks for your time, Healthy Discussion is highly appreciated.

Wasalam,

[email protected]

12

Question

In Sahih al-Bukhari Hadith: 3.227

Hasrat Omar (R.A) himself used to act on his own opinions, contrary to the Code of Islam. He himself has admitted saying: " Husana Bida" (excellent innovation) When he introduced the Taraweeh Prayers.

If taraweeh prayers were sunnah then why did he refer to them as GOOD BIDDA???

13

[QUOTE]
Originally posted by Faisal: *
Taraweeh is a **naffil*. Just keep that in mind.
[/QUOTE]

and i always thought that it is sunnah mauakadah.........

if it is then intentionannly not praying will be a sin..........but rozzay will inshallah be accepted in that case too...

14

Asalam o Alakum

[QUOTE]
and i always thought that it is sunnah mauakadah.........

if it is then intentionannly not praying will be a sin..........but rozzay will inshallah be accepted in that case too...

[/QUOTE]

All these hypothesis are made by them who want to propagate the Bidah of Taraweeh that it is linked with your Roza (sawm). Actually there is no such thing.

regards,

Wasalam

[email protected]
www.answering-ansar.org

15

Friend …may be the guy who asked the question already knows whether it is bidah or not…so u dont have to clarify things here…u dont like tarwaeeh …dont read it…wait for the dooms day …( Lakum deenaukum wali ya deen)…

according to us anything which is accepted by sahbahs is also islam as sahbah were the best jugde to interpret Hazoor :saw: sunnah …if that is not true then all islamic sources r doubtfull…in that case islams very existence is to be questioned thats is why westerner s always try to put finger on sahbahs…

16

lets focus on the question at hand, and not turn it into another lame shia-sunni bickering.

bao bihari.. to the best of my knowledge, even Prophet :saw: did not pray it all the time, just to make sure that the ummah does not consider it mandatory, so I doubt if it is sunnat-e-mukada. Although, ofcourse, Prophet :saw: would pray a lot in Ramadhan, and so should we. But that does not increase the status of taraweeh, per se. I have not heard or read any credible evidence which suggests not praying taraweeh will influence your roza.

17

Thanks Brother Faisal:

Brother bao bihari:

If we know a thing and consider it good, then it is our responsibility to pass it on. And tell other people. This is Amar bil Maroof – Nahe anil Munkar.

Many of the people after prophet Muhammad (PBUH) have done enough effort the make the Islamic sources doubtful. But it was Allah will to save it forever.

We can not generalize it and give this credit to all those people who are so called Sahaba. The definition of Sahaba is different in different school of thoughts in Muslims. Even different Ullema in same sect define it differently.

Not All the Sahabas are the best judge to interpret of Sunnah. Instead of typing any of my comments, just I would like to invite you to read the following Hadith from Muslim.

When Admin see that the comments are going against his religion and are unanswerable by anyone he stops the discussion and block the thread.
regards,

Wasalam

[email protected]
www.answering-ansar.org

18

[QUOTE]
*Originally posted by inuit: *
Thanks Brother Faisal:

Brother bao bihari: If we know a thing and consider it good, then it is our responsibility to pass it on. And tell other people. This is Amar bil Maroof – Nahe anil Munkar.Many of the people after prophet Muhammad (PBUH) have done enough effort the make the Islamic sources doubtful. But it was Allah will to save it forever.

We can not generalize it and give this credit to all those people who are so called Sahaba. The definition of Sahaba is different in different school of thoughts in Muslims. Even different Ullema in same sect define it differently.Not All the Sahabas are the best judge to interpret of Sunnah. Instead of typing any of my comments, just I would like to invite you to read the following Hadith from Muslim.When Admin see that the comments are going against his religion and are unanswerable by anyone he stops the discussion and block the thread.
regards,

Wasalam

[email protected]
www.answering-ansar.org
[/QUOTE]

It seems that people cannot prove anything through
debate and they just start to throw insults.
Please, grow up. And let it be a debate without insults.
Just debate with respect.

19

Bao Bhiari
I like your name a lot. Ok. Back to the topic at hand.
Please, try to prove your point without getting emotional.
Even if people are abusive.

take care

20

I think you only read the part of the post which was red marked.

Dont switch the topic:

Thanks Brother Faisal:

Brother bao bihari:

If we know a thing and consider it good, then it is our responsibility to pass it on. And tell other people. This is Amar bil Maroof – Nahe anil Munkar.

Many of the people after prophet Muhammad (PBUH) have done enough effort the make the Islamic sources doubtful. But it was Allah will to save it forever.

We can not generalize it and give this credit to all those people who are so called Sahaba. The definition of Sahaba is different in different school of thoughts in Muslims. Even different Ullema in same sect define it differently.

Not All the Sahabas are the best judge to interpret of Sunnah. Instead of typing any of my comments, just I would like to invite you to read the following Hadith from Muslim.

regards,

Wasalam

[email protected]
www.answering-ansar.org

Note: rehman1! is this insulting now ?