Lets say the same terrorists/students holed up in a mosque in India and Indian army had done the same operation.
I wonder what you guys and pakistan’s in general opinion would have been if Indian army killed hundreds of terrorists in the same fashion.
would it be the same as now or it would be different.?
serious and honest replies are appreciated.
Flammers go to the thread above this one.
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
Really good question....I was actually wondering the same thing the last couple of days when this whole lal masjid situation was happening.
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
Honestly if the correct facts are gauranteed to reach you then it would be easier to choose a side. However muslims being in India have to abide by the Laws of India and if they do against them knowingly then there is not much to side with. I think however the mass public opinion of Pakistan would be against the Indian action knowing how our people think.
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
Lal Majit of Pak = India's Golden Temple
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
India already did its called Gujarat massacre....
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
India already did its called Gujarat massacre....
You make NO SENSE..
India's Gujrat riots = mostly innocent civilians killed, very few extremist retards killed = SHOULD NOT HAVE HAPPENED
Pakistan's Lal Masjid = mostly extremist retards killed, very few innocent civilians killed = SHOULD HAVE HAPPENED
How can you compare them?
Anyway, Back to the topic... if sumthing like this happened in India... the reaction would be totally different.. even if there was enough proof most pakistanis would think its a conspiracy... and mullahs would use it to spread anti-india hatred
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
^^ If a bunch of hindu fanatics take over a temple and Pak Army forces them out...
Wouldn't you think its a conspiracy?
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
No I wouldn't... I think you have forgotten that I'm not really a regular Hindu..or an Indian.... I dont have any bias.. I assess the situation from a neutral point always... I'm kind of forced to do that...with my background..
Fanatics are fanatics.. hindu muslim sikh christian or jews.. if they take over any religious place of worship and do crap like the lal masjid retards did... they should be invaded and killed..
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
You make NO SENSE..
India's Gujrat riots = mostly innocent civilians killed, very few extremist retards killed = SHOULD NOT HAVE HAPPENED Pakistan's Lal Masjid = mostly extremist retards killed, very few innocent civilians killed = SHOULD HAVE HAPPENED
How can you compare them?
Anyway, Back to the topic... if sumthing like this happened in India... the reaction would be totally different.. even if there was enough proof most pakistanis would think its a conspiracy... and mullahs would use it to spread anti-india hatred
I am not comparing innocent muslims with fanatics, the point being when a fanatic hindu govt. can kill so many innocent muslims and get away with it you think fanatics killing fanatics will make any difference.
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
^^ ??? bro ur not making any sense... you compared the lal masjid raid to gujrat riots... and im saying thats stupid to do...
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
^^ ??? bro ur not making any sense... you compared the lal masjid raid to gujrat riots... and im saying thats stupid to do...
Gujarat cannot be compared with anything let alone Lal Masjid, the story of Gujarat is all over Human Rights web site.. The point still stands IF so many innocent muslims are burned alive and nothing happened do you think killing fanatics would make any difference?
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
kakay, forget india, wanna bet in two months time majority of pakistanis will be blaming the pak govt for the lal masjid "massacre of 1000s of innocent believers".
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
Gujarat cannot be compared with anything let alone Lal Masjid, the story of Gujarat is all over Human Rights web site.. The point still stands IF so many innocent muslims are burned alive and nothing happened do you think killing fanatics would make any difference?
There you go.. you said it urself that it cannot be compared with lal masjid... where on your previous post you clearly said "india alreayd had such an incident (similar to lal masjid).. gujrat riots"
*"IF so many innocent muslims are burned alive and nothing happened do you think killing fanatics would make any difference?"
*I still don't understand your point. How does burning of innocent muslims in India relate to deaths of fanatics in Pakistan?
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
There you go.. you said it urself that it cannot be compared with lal masjid... where on your previous post you clearly said "india alreayd had such an incident (similar to lal masjid).. gujrat riots"
*"IF so many innocent muslims are burned alive and nothing happened do you think killing fanatics would make any difference?"
*I still don't understand your point. How does burning of innocent muslims in India relate to deaths of fanatics in Pakistan?
Seems like you are having comprehension problems or you are like going in circles.
Here it is one more time hope it will sink...
If a fanatic hindu govt. can kill so many innocent muslims and get away with it do you think it will make any difference if the same hindu fanatics would kill muslim fanatics? ... makes sense or still difficult.
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
Seeing how Abdail's mind works, it's obvious that if a lal masjid situation had happened in India and the Indian army was sent to handle the Muslim militants, the Indian army would've been called the "terrorists" and the muslim militants would've been called "freedom fighters". "struggling to fight off the Indian rule" such words would've been used for the militant terrorists by people like Abdail.
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
^ Ah it hurts ain’t it, especially the truth when Indian terrorist in uniform kill or rapes they are not terrorist, or if fanatic hindus burn muslims alive they are not fanatics… EH!!! Now is that a double standard or is that a double standard.
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
Lal Majit of Pak = India's Golden Temple
uske baad kya hua ?
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
yaar add something new, fresh. Pichchle kai saalon se is tarah ki cheenta kashi ki vaardaat chal rahi hai.
Re: If India did it, what would be your opinion.
Lets say the same terrorists/students holed up in a mosque in India and Indian army had done the same operation.
I wonder what you guys and pakistan's in general opinion would have been if Indian army killed hundreds of terrorists in the same fashion.
I would support the Indian Army. Terrorists are terrorists. They need to be stopped.
It is now becoming clear to many people what Israel, India and other countries have had to put up with for many years.