How to free Pakistani society from Mullahs

[ravage]

Re: How to free Pakistani society from Mullahs

@diwana

Hence not all what he said be considered literally.
Only a fool will think he neant All Mullahs. Right?

And only a fool will keep defending ‘All Mullahs’, when he is the only one talking about ‘All Mullahs’.

Then you came a little closer to me by saying he meant the median kind.

You need to come further since what you are saying is

1- In a perfectly symmetrical bell curve, half of mullahs are fake. Not true. In that case we would be seeing one of two on average being fake. In reality not even one in four are fake. A lot of muslims witness that in their lives.

2- In an skewed population of mullahs, that median may be anywhere. so I do not think you meant median of skewed bell curve.

Both ways you are wrong when saying “he talked about median residing mullahs”. Yo just made it up to make a point. Got it?

with respect to both 1 and 2, those are your opinions on what the ‘fake’ Mullahs are. Im not sure what fakery has to do with anything, where the question of them being fake came from, and what standards we are judging fakeness against. Your attempts at statistical definition are laughable.. the bell curve wont mean that ‘half of mullas are fake’ (why?!). Suffice it to say, in everyday discourse neither median, nor typical are hard to understand words.

You wish to obfuscate the issue when it is very plain and simple. Iqbal referred to Mullas as a class. No he wasnt referring to every single Mullah on Earth. Simultaneously there is no basis to assume that he was excluding most mullas and only referring to the mullay YOU find objectionable. The common sense view would be that just as I say birds fly and dont mean Ostrich and that is easy to understand for most people, without expecting people to launch into speculations on how I could mean Ostrich, how birds might not be literal, how we might want to consider the distribution of birds yada yada yada.. Iqbal says Din-e-Mullah fee sabilillah fasad. Its a simple misra, without any qualifiers that would leave room for your interpretive dance.

---

So do you or do you not agree with:

Deen e kafir fikr o tadbeer e jahad

Third time

I agree to the extent that intellectual and technological endeavour is in the hands of those whom Iqbal would regard as ‘kafir’. I am more of a fan of the second misra, has a real ring of truth to it.