Look dear, when you want to test validity of logic/methodology, you gotta put in some extreme value in it. To see what result it gives. I kept the logic same, just put some ‘extreme’ facts out there. Too bad you are drifting deeper and deeper into the aunty territory
PS: You said
What is being asked is, is the drinking a valid ‘requirement’/‘disclosure’ in such a case or not. You gave example of Job and Roommate, both irrelevant to the topic at hand.