Honest opinions needed

I don’t know if youll say i am over protective or what but i just want to know your opinions on if i did the right thing in these two situations involving Family members,
Fortunately my Husband supports me in both, and as he was not on the spot says i did the right thing and he would have ended up making the situation worse cos these are my family members

Situation 1:

Back in March we were at a family wedding and it’s near the end, Hubby was qued up to get tea, i was holding my son on my hip, turned facing towards hubby and using hand gestures letting him know how many cups of tea we needed.

Baby is in held in a firm grip he was about 8-9 months then, so always wanted to get down to crawl hence the firm grip.
Next thing i know is that i feel him being pulled from my hold, turn to see who it is, it’s one of my mom’s brothers, my Mamu.

He has my son now, and i shout/get really angry at him in the hall infront of 2 -3 other aunts and uncles saying along the lines of

“how dare you take my son from me like that, who are you to do that”

one of my Khala’s (mum’s sister) is telling me to calm down and stop with the scene, and i am so totally furious i walk away from there to calm myself down,
stupidly leaving my son there. Of course i know he will be safe, but can Mamu not have ASKED to hold him? instead of yank him?

told my Ammi about it while still in the Hall, i have no idea if she spoke to her brother or not, or if she said anything later, got NO feedback

Situation 2:

we’re at my cousin’s Nikaah function, travelled to Loindon on a sunday evening for it, it’s late night now 11:30, ruksati still hasn’t happened and my son is getting highly agitated, Hubby says to go,
My cousin’s mom knew we may leave early, and had asked us during the function if we would, at the time baby had been fine and we’d said we would see how it goes.

i was talking to my mom to let her know that baby was now too tired and we were going to leave, she said that “you were going to stay till the end” i said “He’s upset now, so we’re gonna make our way home,”
at this point My khala pipes in and says

“it doesn’t make a difference if you stay longer”
that was the red flag for me and i was like, “it makes no difference to you but it does to me”
she say’s “my son is in bed at 9.00 every night” (her son is 8-9 Years old)
i ignored that and had 2nd Khala telling me that i should not have spoken to her like that
my reaction,
“i’m talking to my mom, i don’t need any body telling me it does not make a difference”

point to note, the night before we had been at my mom’s i had put baby to bed on time but he woke up after half an hour and my dad brought him down, :smack: and we got home but he didn’t sleep til after 1 am!

i had told my mom about his late night the night before and she knew his sleep had been upset for the past few days.

Re: Honest opinions needed

I think you could have been less rude in both situations, but I'm not one to talk, because I tend to be rude to my elders when I am feeling disrespected.

I think you over-reacted in the first situation, but I guess it depends on your relationship with your Mamu.

Re: Honest opinions needed

totally overreacted in the first situation.. and could have been less rude in the 2nd. :)

Re: Honest opinions needed

just to clarify, My mamu always tries to annoy the life out of me, doesn't respect the fact i am now married and have a child, i.e. does not treat me like and adult.

Re: Honest opinions needed

I agree you over reacted in first situation and you were rude in the second.

If he did it in a way that hurt you or the baby then I would say that he is a gorilla not a man. If neither you or baby got hurt in the process then a video should be posted to make an informed decision and pass a judgment.

no video unfortunately,
and the baby was grabbing onto me cos he was being pulled from behind

Re: Honest opinions needed

Sorry but I agree. You definitely overreacted in the 1st situation. REgardless of however your relationship is, you didn't need to be so rude. Could have simply said mamu, please just ask me to hold my son..etc...that's all...it;s not a big deal.

Second scenario, again you were a bit rude. It's a norm that people insist you stay for wedding etc. You simply state your case & move along....no need for comments etc.

but i'd already said he was tired, then when some one says that it doesn't make a difference it's like WHAT??

to add , she is a mother herself, i think some kind of understanding would have been expected.

Re: Honest opinions needed

Hmm I guess the first was a bit of an over reaction but I get that youre a mother and stuff like this can be a little daunting, i.e the baby could have fallen. Second situation I think I'd have to agree with the others, could have been less rude but I totally see your point too. Maybe work on you communication skills? If you want respect you have to give it too.

Re: Honest opinions needed

^ Yeah, I agree.

Re: Honest opinions needed

Mamababa, Whilst I agree with others feedback here , I can also see your perspective , I feel you should have just ignored their comments and moved on .. rather then responding in any way. Specially when one is in family gatherings one must respect the fact that any wrong attitude from you is going to leave a mark on everyone around.

And it would have only been in the best interest of everyone , that you indicated your hurt later on a one to one basis with your khala or mamu calmly.

Re: Honest opinions needed

Chicken i know what you mean, and i’m pretty sure that the whole family knows about these incidents and i am cast as the bad guy :hinna:

but i was just like SO SO angry,
my husband described me as a protective lioness when her child is being attacked or hurt in some way.

Re: Honest opinions needed

u overreacted in both situation.

Re: Honest opinions needed

You totally over-reacted in both of the situations. I am sure your Mamoo couldn’t have yanked your baby from your arms. Your Mamoo must be quite hurt by your behavior.

Don't mind my words, but you really have to control your tongue. If you don't learn to control your tongue you will end up like the black sheep in the family who no one likes.

Try to find ways to control your anger. :)

I do see where your coming from, but again there is a way to do it nicely. Also did your mamu really "yank" the baby & put it at harm...or in general how people wanna hold your kid...there is big difference. There was a better way to handle that.

I do understand baby was tired & you told em, but you should have just moved along. Again it's how you speak that makes all the difference. Esp in a big gathering of family, it is how you speak & handle yourself. In such a situation state your case & move along. People maybe just want you to stay longer, I doubt they meant to be mean or ignorant or anything.

Mamababa, I think its only fair to say that they are baby’s someone as well …
One day your baby will grow up inshallah and you will want him to interact with family or learn to respect elders ( baby’s khala’s and mamu’s and other rishtay )

But If you are going to be so overprotective , it will finish off good relations with your loved ones . and that would be very selfish on your part as you have just deprived the baby of the love that he deserved from his relatives …

Being protective is good , but if it becomes extreme , then its a problem for you, your baby, your loved ones. I hope you take this positively ..

Re: Honest opinions needed

You could have avoided both scenes.You should have been soft in the first instance and in the second one,you could have been more diplomatic.

Re: Honest opinions needed

Learn to respect your elders and you were totally out of line in the first incident.

How was your child being hurt/ attacked?

I think your Hubby only said those things to you as he knows he has to live with you whereas your Mamoo and Khala's get to go to their own homes after! Your husband must know how sensitive you are and if I was in his position – I would definitely say the same things to you as him, knowing that I had to live with you too.

You were not a protective lioness. I think your behavior had little to do with your baby and mostly with you being incapable of controlling your anger. You did express your feelings towards your Mamoo before in an earlier post.

You came here asking for advice. I am giving you truthful advice. Sometimes it isn’t nice to hear honest opinions, but do want us all to lie and tell you what you did was right, when it wasn't? Sometimes we have to own up to when we overreacted and are in the wrong. Also, remember that you baby is picking up and learning everything from you. You could have avoided both those incidents just by remaining calm.

Sorry if my words sound so harsh. I am not attacking you in anyway and I really hope things work out for you. Work on controlling your anger and remember to bite your tongue next time you feel upset. You can't take those words back once you said them. Perhaps you could go round to see your Mamoo/ Khala and work things out with them. :)