If ur not into Italian food it's probably cuz u haven't been to a great Italian restaurant yet. What pizza place did u go to in little Italy? I just went to this Italian place near my home named Vezzo, has the most amazing gourmet pizza. There are so many great pizza places around the city. The next one on my list is Adriennes pizza bar, downtown. Love it!
I forget hte name but its on 187th street (the Bronx Little Italy, not in the city). good stuffs. Yum.