Help Me (cont'd from HF)

yes the problem I am facing is more bigger but first of all I would like to write some background here

I did love marriage and as a husband trust me my hubby is very loving beside that problem I discussed before

My in laws are totally illiterate and wild my sister in law beat me 2 times in these last 2 years (my husband protest against her behave ) she is elder them him and engaged and two more younger sisters who are really BADTAMIZ

I have only an old father behind and 2 elder married sisters no brother

My husband favor me he never believe on her mother and sister and say clearly that He don’t believe them and My wife is in trouble because of you ppl
The problem is that we are not in the position to be separate due to social pressure as my husband bit scared of his DAM father and the biggest reason is that ppl will say about him that “BIWI K LEY JAWAN UN MARRIED BEHNOO KO AUR MAA KO CHOR DIA”
He is suffering too with me even when ever I tried to go to my fathers house and leaving him (which actually my in laws want ) he became worried and even cried some times
Now the question is what should I do against the WORST EST behave of in laws in hoo nay tany day k aur galiyan even day kar mujhy takleef mai dala hoa hai
I am not a strong women I came scared when ever in laws shout at me or somthing else
Now plz guide me what should I do to live respectably and happy I will again say my husband is full supporting me caring me but I have to face them when he is out for work and I want to prove that I am not WEAK which actually I am :frowning: I cant live without my hubby I cant leave my place

Re: help me

even my sister is advising me that leave that bloody house but I love my hubby a lot I will die with out him and the behave of my in laws is killing me tooo

Re: help me

.

Re: help me

Rida,

First of all you will NOT DIE without ure husband, you lived so many years without him..im not saying leave him but i am saying make sure your life doesnt depend on him.

Your situation is much more complex than we first thought!

Ok first of all, you say your in-laws are illeterate and wild, so who cared what they think. You are an intelligent mature woman who cares what they think their opinion came from one brain cell. Also i cant believe your SIL hit you! She has no right to do that, atleast your husband defended you but defend yourself! Move away and tell her she has NO RIGHT to lay one finger on you no matter what....she is going off soon to her in laws so thats good news for you.

In terms of making yourself attractive, everyone is right. Do things for YOU. Honestly it works, i have experienced it myself. The minute you put yourself first, dress for you, put your make up on for you etc etc men come running. The more you try and get their attention the more they dont give it to you because they know you want them.

Also remember that we are normal woman not pornstars...sorry to ask this question...but does you husband read mens magazines or look at stuff online...because maybe thats where he gets 'ideas' from about what is attractive.....

Re: help me

I am just so shocked at the things I am reading in this thread, husband seems like a jackass sorry, SIL hit you? Wild and jahil PILs, lady you got urself in such a crappy mess.

yes i m in hell but still the only and only reason for living there is my hubby other wise i dam care that what my relatives in case I back to my dads home How should I face them ? If I say a single word my Father in law strictly notice me even my sister in law and her mother going to hit me in a while even if they kill me I will be help less because they are more strong then me

Re: help me

Why are you putting yourself through this! This is not what life should be!

Put yourself first, you are the most important to you.

You and your husband should move away.

You are in my prayers

Re: help me

jazak allah jin larkiyo ki maa nahi hoti in ko dua ki sab say zada zarorat hoti hai mujhy bhi hai

Re: help me

my hubby is saying just wait for 2-3 months more but bardasht ki har had lagta hai khatam hai

Re: help me

how good/bad are your finances? who is the bread-earner of the house? cant you guys have a 2 storied house with separate entrances where you can live on the top floor with your husband and the rest of the family on the ground floor? or maybe you're already living like this, i dont know ...

and where do boobs come in all this mess? in my view boobs are kind of lost in this whole new story you've put forth ...

perhaps you need to get in touch with a social worker who works with women tangled in domestic violence and get proper protection. no need to get separation if you guys are in love ... you just need to figure out a way to part your ways with your in-laws while still maintaining a healthy relationship with your husband. that in itself is going to be a hefty task.

We are living in already triple story house GROUND floor my dadi saas mother in law of my sass is living with her 2 daughter in laws
1St me and my mother in law are living
2ND FLOOR my father in law and her SECOND WIFE are living there already

my whole expense is carried by my hubby he has average salary but enough for us as my father in law is carrying the house expense and my hubby also give money to her mother to stay here other wise she will kick him immediately
the situation in im living is worst so i forge ten every thing including my breast problem and every thing

Re: Help Me (cont'd from HF)

what will happen if you answer them in the same manner? ask ur hubby where is duniya ki batain when ur in laws beat u? stand up for urself and tell ur husband that he shd move out its ur right. hell with dunya and its dwellers.

Re: Help Me (cont'd from HF)

If your husband is giving money to his mother to stay there, he can give his money to another landlord and find a small place for you both to rent.

Your accomodation options are NOT limited to either stay with his family or your family. As far as I am aware, rental accomodation is alot more easily affordable in Pakistan than in western countries, as in most of the salary is not spent on rent.

Find somewhere else to live within your means.

.

Re: Help Me (cont'd from HF)

In a situation like this , limit your dealing /conversation with the inlaws ... try to ignore coming infront of them ... in other words , start drawing a visible distance between yourself and them , that way you might be able to reduce unnecessary tentions or them finding another opportunity to abuse you.

In the meantime , keep talking to your husband and start planning when would be the right time for you two to move out. I dont think you must consider leaving your husband coz you love him and he is supportive of you. and he is definitely not enjoying being the middle man either .... so start planning the exit strategy , from this house...

look for answers to the following questions :

Whats holding your husband back into the house?
If its the finances , how can you save or find additional resources to afford a separate living.

If its the husbands wish to get the sisters married first before he moves out , then push your husband to look for proposals , help him with the search .. so that together you two can get over with the responsiblity ..

We are just listening to your side of the story , inlaws might have their own side of the story, ask yourself , if you are unknowingly provoking them in anyway? if you are satisfied that you are not , then tell your husband that in the current circumstancs the best strategy is that you refrain yourself to your part of the house , only go to the kitchen or where ever , if absolutely necessary. This is to avoid any further conflicts ... until you find better and permanent solutions to this issue.

is there any other member in the house who is leel headed? your FIL for example? or any other influential member in their family , like an elder ? involve them in finding proposals for the SIL's ... just focus on that , the quicker that happens the better it will be for your husband and you .....

i agree ... but rent i also know is not so less either because the earning capacity per head is not as high as in western countries ... i don't know what your husband earns rida ... but i do know when a starter (professional bachelor's holder) begins with a job, he/she starts between 18000 and 25000 ... and the rent is crazy high when coupled with utility bills and etc.
where do you live btw, what city? rents are also of course quite varied according to where you live.

Totally agree.

Re: Help Me (cont'd from HF)

everyone has given you really good advice and i suggest you think about trying to get your own place especially if your husband is supportive of you!

Also in the origional thread you kept saying 'abnormality' you are NOT abnormal you are a perfectly normal beautiful woman :)

Re: Help Me (cont'd from HF)

Is this for real?

Hi Rida,

A few tears and supportive words mean very little if no action is taking place. Actions speak LOUDER than words.

You say that your husband is supportive and sympathetic, but unfortunately he is not strong enough to take action. Humdardi ka kya faida....jab k tumharay husband main itni himmat nahin k woh tumhay zulm se bachaye. Humdardi k kuch lafz to koi bhi bol sakta hai.....aansoo bahana bhi koi bari baat nahin hai..........LEKIN........in se tumhay kya faida ho ga? Tum khud ko kamzor samajhti ho......LEKIN.....tumhara husband to tum ze bhi ziyada....balke mazeed kamzor hai.

It is your husband's Islamic responsibility to protect you. I've heard that a husband should arrange a separate living arrangement for his wife if her in-laws are creating problems. Someone correct me if I'm wrong about this.

You cannot spend the rest of your life tolerating zulm at the hands of your in-laws. And your husband can't spend the rest of his life crying like a helpless baby. Even if your husband can't afford to move out and live separately.........Allah made him a man and he needs to be strong and take some action. He is not doing his mother and sister any favor by allowing them continue their abuse.

Tumhara husband.....chup baith ne se........apni maa aur behan par koi ehsaan nahin kar raha. Aur maa/baap/behan se darnay ka tumharay husband ko Allah ki taraf se koi sawab nahin mil raha. Maa/baap agar ghalat kaam kar rahain hain....ya ghalat naseeyat de rahain hain.........to Islam ijazat deta hai k hum un ki na sunain...........aur woh kaam karain jo k sahih hai.

Do you know why your mother-in-law and sister-in-law don't listen to your husband? Tumhay pata hai k tumhari saas aur nand tumharay husband par itna rob kyoon chalati hain???????? IS LIYE KYOON K SAAS KO PATA HAI K US KA BETA (tumhara husband) kamzor hai aur stand nahin le ga.

Jab hum doosron ko baar baar dikhatain hain k hum bahut kamzor hain.......to log utni hi dafa faida uthayain gay. LEKIN........agar hum doosron ko dikhayain k hum strong hain.....hum kisi ki badtameezi ko nahin sahay gain........hum main confidence hai........hum apne pairon par kharay ho sakte hain................to doosra banda humain tang karne se pehlay hazaar dafa sochay ga!

Basically, sweetheart, your husband needs to grow a pair of balls. And in my opinion........you need to tell your husband that you can't tolerate this abuse because it is affecting your health..........and then go live with your father. IF your husband cries like a baby.............then YOU TELL HIM THAT HE NEEDS TO TAKE ACTION. Tumharay husband ko kuch karna hoga. Varna tum aik na khatam honay walay cycle main phas jaao gi jahan woh log tumharay saath zulm karay gain aur tumhara husbad rota jaaye ga phir woh aur zulm karay gain phir husband aur roye ga. Jab tak k tumahara husband apnay haaton main y situation na lay........yeh situation repeat hoti jaye gi. Husband k parents ko maza aata hoga yeh soch kar k un ka baita itna kamzor hai aur easily control kiya jaa sakta hai.

Maybe you can live with your father for a while.......and your husband can save some money to rent an apartment........and then you both can move to a separate living arrangement. ALSO............tell your father about what is happening. And ask your father to talk to your in-laws about their behavior.

Your in-laws sound dangerous. What will happen when you become pregnant? How will they treat you then? If they don't respect you now, how will they treat you when you have children.

Tell your husband that you will be living with your father for some time.........and tell him that "Ronay se koi faida nahin hoga. Agar tumhari apni behan aisay azab se guzar rahi ho...aur agar us ka shohar bhi us k liye stand na lay.....to tumhay kaisa feel hota. It's time to take some action. "

I don't know why your in-laws are mistreating you......but the only other strategy that I can think of is for you to be nice to them. Don't argue with them. If you are instigating or fueling arguments, then you need to stop. If it is impossible for you to live with your father and if you have no other choice but to live with your in-laws.......then try being patient with them and kill them with kindness if it helps.