Hazrat Isa A.S.

[psyah]

Re: Hazrat Isa A.S.

@kchughtai

Yes I meant surah-e-maida. The death of Jesus(as) is very clear from this one. Even if you don’t take tawaffee to be death, still it makes his death clear.
If Tawaffee means death then the only fact that his followers made him and his mother Gods after his death, testifies that he has died already
If Tawaffee remains a question mark for a moment even then it is clear that he has died. He remained witness over them till his tawaffee. There is no mention of any 2nd coming. no mention of him being aware of their shirk. no mention of him being witness over his people again. Yet another verse 4:159 suggests that he will be witness on his people on the judgment day. no mention of him being witness over them before that.

If this event is yet to take place - i.e. at the Day of Judgement as you yourself said many posts ago - then we can say only one thing for sure - that Isa (AS) will die before the Day of Judgement … we cannot conclude that it has already happened … but we can say that it might have happened and might not yet.