Hazrat Isa A.S.

[psyah]

Re: Hazrat Isa A.S.

@kchughtai

What is the problem with you? I was responding to fairyangel’s question. and the question was weaved around ONE word ‘Mutawafeeqa’ and not the issue of life or death of Isa(as). She pointed out translations as if all are translating it that way and why we are resorting to the translation ‘cause thee to die a natural death’. I presented some translations to show her other side of the picture.

Certainly, I am not an authorithy over you neither your stance has any binding on me. We are presenting our views and you are yours. why do you feel threatened. It is upto Allah to give guidance to the right path no matter how hard anyone tries. So stay cool. present your view and let me present mine.

Peace kchughtai

Look I don’t have a problem translating it as " cause you to die" … But then I invoke that time to still be pending. Allah (SWT) will still cause Isa(as) to die and it has not happened yet.

So take your pick … That Isa (as) is alive and Allah (SWT) will cause him (as) to die, in the second coming or Allah (SWT) has taken him up to Himself …

Either way … The initial argument is about refuting the notion that "the Qur’an says for a fact that Isa(as) has died …