Hazrat Isa A.S.

[psyah]

Re: Hazrat Isa A.S.

@Mr.Popat

Plural or not.. how does that even matter? its not me shifting the focus of the topic but rather you. You fail to understand this simple logic. You die and therefore SOMETHING goes up, and that something is soul. Messengers(angels) take them away , as is said in other verse. Allah does not need to say ‘ruh’ in these verses as Allah already said he takes soul in 2 occasions. Sleep and death. If you’re not sleeping and Allah takes away your soul, then you’re DEAD ! ! !

.

Peace Mr.Popat

Yes, in those verses where it specifically states souls are being taken, then that is the case … Otherwise there are deeper insights of the word tawaffee … That perhaps you have not realised …

When death takes someone … Notice the taking (tawaffee) done by death (mawt) will always be on the whole person … It takes hold of the whole person … Separates the soul from the body then let’s them go … Here death is used to represent the actions of the angel of death.

The many years later perhaps after judgement another tawaffee is done, this time only on the soul …

Or during life … A person sleeps, the body feels nothing, but the soul does … It is taken without the connection to the body being severed … So this is another type of tawaffee …

Sometimes whilst in this state, death comes … So the connection severed while the soul is stretched away from the body … Or death does not come and the soul is allowed to bounce back in to the body …

Here the tawaffee of death is a whole person experience … It is felt by the body and the soul … So tawaffee does not have to be only on the soul … But when it is on the soul alone, we can say that either the person is asleep or going to die or who has died …

However, another tawaffee can take place … And that is where the whole body is taken … And then returned (Nuzul).