Hazrat Isa A.S.

[psyah]

Re: Hazrat Isa A.S.

@Mughal1

Dear psyah, it seems that you are having problems with maze of words and their meanings. Dictionary meaning are only helpful in the sense that they bring to our attention various way of looking at the word however to choose the right meaning we must have objective. The quran uses many words with many diffeent meanings yet its objective only become clear when its texts are looked at its objectively and within its context. Just because a word is used in the quran in various places does not mean at all that it is use in the same sense everywhere. This is where are you seem to be stuck I assume.

…

hope this helps, regards and all the best.

Peace Mughal1

You are only repeating to me what I have been saying all along … Sorry can’t give that away to you … reading in the appropriate context is my argument …

It is because the context mandates it that we say that Isa (AS) was taken whole … any other applied meaning dumbs the sense of it down and conflicts with the context.

The question is what is the context … !!!

Look you bring the context of the verses around why Isa (AS) cannot be taken up alive and I’ll bring the context of why he must have been … then let’s resume our discussion …