Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

Why is it in our culture that human beings wish ‘aulad e nareena’ for themselves but katti from the buffaloes and cows?

Do we weight aulad (our own and of our herds) as to how beneficial it would be for us in future?

No doubt there is a slight shift in society for accepting daughters, but we still hear ’ bete to choR kar chale jate hain, betiyan to wafa karti hain’.

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

whts aulad e nareena :bummer: ?

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

male offspring

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

they usually want a male offspring for carryign the name...you know nasal barhana

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

Isn't it another form of discrimination that nasal mard se hi aage barhegi?

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

Thts how islam has it i think :bummer: k dunya mai kid dad ke naam se hota hai…but Day of judgement mai mom ke name se pukara jata hai…
i THINK …

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

But we especially our Shia brothers consider the children of Hazrat Fatima as children of the Prophet.

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

pata nai :bummer:

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

@muqawwee bhai sunni bhi to hazrat Fatima ki aulad ko Huzoor :saw2: ki Aal kehte hain…:slight_smile:

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

Yes ninja many Sunni also follow this concept. Whats your view on this wish of having male offspring. Is it due to expected future benefits or something else?

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

@LP apko satyamev jayate ke first episode ki yaad nahi aayi....

Female foeticide is one of social issues in INdia....

Indian me girls ka ratio boys ke muqabil kaafi kum hai

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

yes...but thts cuz of a diff reason...cuz girls are considered a bojh...unke shadi pe itna kharch jo kerna parta hai

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

Some how I’m sure that India main bail ke muqabile main gae ziada pai jati hongi :hehe:

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

Girls are not burden.. The stupid traditions of society are burden.

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

cows ko maarna mana bhi hai wahan

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

But same is the situation in Pakistan where cow is not religiously important

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

ppl look at it this way MAYBE , ke wht they invest on their daughters isnt returned to them...but wht they invest on their sons in education , marriage etc is returned to them when the son earns and takes care of them financially , gets married and brings a bahu to take care of them , and brings kids unki nasal chalaney ke liye.

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

@muqawwee bhai My nani's father had 5 daughters .....from two wives.............:D

He used to say ke Allah kamaz kam ek awara beta hi de deta....

he used to choose name for boys maga r jab larki hoti to ussi naam ko larkion wala kar dete the...

Iqbal,shahid-shaheda,khalid-Khaleda,gaus-gausia....:D

I think reason for desire for male offspring was due to social status of women at that time...

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

:hehe:…bail to aaj bhi hindustan ke kai ghar chalata hai …khet me kaam karke

Re: Hawa ki beti Vs Bhens ki katti

My khala and chacha have 4 sons and they want daughters :(