Have Muslims made a mockery of Islam?

[psyah]

Re: Have Muslims made a mockery of Islam?

@kchughtai

Ahh I wish I could agree to you. :). I hope for better in the future:hypo:

What was happening is a different story. I was talking about what was in the treaty. you presented half the truth. didn’t talk about the clause where a person leaving the ranks of muslims and going/joining makka will not be returned.

I did talk about it, but the people didn’t leave Islam, they just left Madinah. That was the intent of the treaty.

it was you who presented the half-truth … You didn’t mention the condition of the Hajj and you are making it out that the treaty is about conversion to paganism or Islam, but it is not, it is about keeping people in their place, once they have decided to become Muslim after the treaty they remain Makkans …