yes i heard that too , that when ppl go to jadooo toonas walay , they have captured some evil spirits whom the sent with the concerned person , next time you go there , they tell you everything in detail
another concept is that every person has some shadowy spirits who can be captured and made to do certain things
i think you are refering to Muraqba , but that is different from what you have explained,
it is done for certain reason .
no it is not
i second Fraudz
yes it’s not controlling nafs , it’s controlling other elements of nature having more powers than a human
Clarification: I wasn't talking about hamzaad specifically. I was talking about jinns in general. I don't know the sharai heisiat of the 'jantar mantar' and 'chilla' :). However, doing spiritual healing (roohani ilaaj) is definitely a great virtue (as in the case of a medical doctor).
so 'controlling' hamzad is something appreciated in sharia? and the talk about and time spent in mantar jantar and challa and what nots to control hamzaad is like a farz sunnah or nafil?
dude but when ppl talk about controllign hamzad theyare not talking about controlling their nafs, that much is cleareven from teh first few posts in this thread.
but i know wha u are saying
i was not saying that control their nafs
but actually was saying that they start talking to themself
means they become mad