Hadith and thier Authenticity [Split]

[usmanshahid]

Re: Hadith and thier Authenticity [Split]

@MKF

My criteria definitely is weak and just a proposal based on my limited knowledge and thereby liable to changes but what i was trying to put across is that declaring something explicitly Haraam or Halaal which has neither been declared explicitly nor implicitly Haraam or Halaal by Quran is transgressing our powers. If Hazrat Muhammad wanted to declare something explicitly Haram or Halaal (something not covered in Quran) He would have openly declared it in public meetings and we are sure to find multiple chain of narrators but if only one person comes up and says he heard from him who heard from whom, then we have a right to doubt not the prophet but the chain.

Quran was only told by Hazoor PBUH , why you don’t tell that he was telling lie only he lissen from the Hazrat Jibraeel no one else
just to check he was true or not , surely you will study his life history, then you will judge that he is liar or a true person

same thing is done in case of Hadees , go and check the life history of each narrator
you are only following your own thoughts , come out of that , before you fell more in deapth of darkness

you people are comming again and again with the same post , trying to cause some doubt in the mind of common persons, why don’t you go to some aalim or even you don’t trust them go and buy some authentic book of hadees and check out the criteria of selecting hadees , rather then running the horses of your own thoughts that are leading you to darkness