Re: Imam Ali (as) Saying: Taken from Peak of Eloquence
Jaan Leva nay farmaya
*Those that are not authentic WERE rejected, weren't they? And even when people tried to inject them into the hadith system, they were pulled and were rejected again. *
so you are saying that the compilers were 100% accurate?
*Muslims of that time were much more tolerant and respectful of each other than later years and especially today. *
errr the the current compilations did not get put together for a long time after the prophet's death, and the tolerance of respectfulness of muslims for each other was demonstrated in the murder of a couple of caliphs, torturing and killing the family of the prophet. With that sort of tolerance and respect around, no wonder ppl want to question the stuff that was written in books that took place even further after those incidents.