The way i see things ...
Today there are three kind of muslims 1. who love Ali a.s so much that they call him ALLAH (na-aozobillah) 2. who claim that Imam Ali a.s was just like us .... 3. who are in middle not callin him Allah neither calling him like themselves, calling him Imam Ali a.s
Other way to see this is who is away from rightfulness
calling anyone Allah is shirk. and praising enenmies of Imam Ali is not rightful either So love him enough that u dont praise people who went on wars against em rather do tabara on em and dont love him so much that u compare him with ALLAH.
wasalam Aqeel
your point no. 3 is very very funny, since all aware and thouse persons who read al-kafi fully aware that what you ppl'e beliefs regarding ali ra even islam and quran does not teach us about imammat and there were no claim of imammat from hz. ali ra and his offspring.