Re: Gunmen take hostages in Bangladeshi capital Dhaka
The more this happens, the less words I have to express my anger. I am angry that we have no idea how to stop people from our communities radicalizing. It starts with spreading awareness and condemning violence that very much exists in islam in madrasas and mosques. Saying islam is religion of peace is not enough. Do something about it. It's like the leaders of Spanish inquisition claiming Christianity is a religion of peace and tolerance. Yes, I realize the west gave birth to these terrorist but what they are doing now is no longer revenge, they are killing the innocent in the name of your religion. Won't you step up and defend it?
I also know most of these people joining these terrorist groups have little to no knowledge of Islam and are petty criminals, violent in nature, people. These people have ruined religion for what it is supposed to be for a person. I don't see a lot of Muslims stepping up and telling the imams and scholars of Islam to address this problem and collectively condemn the parts of religion that justify this violence. I know it's not easy and as a muslim, it is cherry picking what you want taught to your youth but if we don't do this, we are either going to lose it al together or there will be more extremists.
What you say is true in many regards, we as a community are failing to address the most pressing issues facing us, and our scholars are not doing enough to take the task of community welfare. The job and role of a scholar should not become limited to the person we respect because he/she has memorized the Quran alone, or knows the hadith alone. A scholar knows how to suggest policies in accordance with the Quran and Sunnah. Unfortunately, that is not happening.
It all starts with regulation of Madrassas. They do good work by providing for the extremely poor who can't afford a traditional schooling experience, but they need oversight.
Waters get muddied when politics is injected into the entire thing, and any effort made to the left, right or center is bound to upset someone. Take for example the fact that KPK Govt. in Pakistan decided to (according to their leadership) regulate a well-known madrassa, and the way to do that they figure is to provide that madrassa a budget which can then be used in the most benefitting manner to bring about a curricular change, and prevent funding from other objectionable sources (name your favorite badguy country)and If that succeeds, of course it would be money well-spent. But you already have detractors like the ruling party which is currently facing corruption allegations of its' own, and the notorious conman known as Zardari taking potshots at the effort from afar.
And then there are the people of the opposite extreme who would want religion taken out of society completely without thinking about how foolish of a suggestion that would be for a society that identifies itself as being Muslim, practice of it being far from completion, but nonetheless.
The entire thing requires an all-around sincere effort. If the political component of the national machinery, the religious component of the national machinery, and the Brass do not create a singular plan, then it's bound to fail because each part of the authority will undermine the other for temporary self-motivated goals.
Unfortunately, the tragic incident of this heinous crime of executing non-muslims at the hands of illiterate fools automatically makes it a religious thing and the opportunists jump at the opportunity to ensure it stays a religious issue so that they can further their agenda.
It's not a religious problem, it's a political problem but the people involved in the incident use whatever means they feel they comprehend according to their limited thinking, even if those means happen to be using the religious text. It's the people that need education, and changing the religious is completely fine, and the religious scripture is wholesome as it always has been. When we start to demand more from our scholars in terms of their credentials, and ensuring that a regulatory body checks to see who is teaching us the truth, and filtering out the soothsayers in the garb of imams, then we'll be fine and religions will mold us into beautiful people who take the property of their neighbor as sacred and protect it and actively fight against hatred, and/or violence. Until that effort takes place at the administrative level, people will keep using whatever they feel justifies their desires, and fools among us will keep attaching religion to them further solidifying the faux shell of a cover to a political and administrative problem.