Re: Got a new pet.... "puppy"
[quote=cucumber]
if that was the case i wouldn't be posting here to see what others think and who says i came here for someone to change my mind? just want to see what islam says about dogs and ur right i'm not gona believe a hadith that contradicts with the quran.
oh and, its sad to see how people are so blind by turning a cultural "NO" into a religious one
People have given you many hadith and you think that you have the authority to declare them as insufficientor contradictory. People have also given you the story of the men in the cave in Surah Kahf, yet once again, that seems to be insufficient for you too. That story merely mentions dogs but does not talk about whether or not to keep them as pets. That's why you want other references but there isn't any except for in the hadith. This is why I said why do you keep asking for proof when you reject hadith? Either way, I was not born in Pakistan and I hate any kind of cultural biddah's that Pakis do so I don't have any cultural biases as far as my deen goes. But, nice try. I base my deen strictly on Qur'an and the Sunnah of Rasul'Allah (SAW).