Google Islam

[submitmj]

@USResident

Dear brother

You cannot even give the names of all 12 Islamic months from the Quran. Kindly provide complementing verses from the Quran for Surah Tauba verses 1-5 and 36-37 which even indicate the names of the months being refered to in these verses. This should be a good exercise for you because you’ll have to get those from the very literature you are turning a blind eye to.

Let me add some more to dent your arguments. Hadith collections existed even during the time of the Prophet SAW. They were just codified and sorted into jurisprudence less than a century after the Prophet SAW demise. The Muwatta of Malik came out in less than a century. The reason for the origin of the hadith collections was because it became the most sought after and esteemed field of study for the muslims after the demise of the Prophet SAW not because people wanted to setup a parallel to the Quran. That is how the science of hadith developed.

Even the Quran was only formally codified after the demise of the Prophet SAW though it existed in scattered form much similar to the way many companions had kept their private journals/collections of hadith. Bukhari was the culmination when the science of hadith reached its peak not its origin.

Your not even able to backup the translations you are posting. Now lets not divert the topic. So far you have not countered any omf my arguments with credible evidence. Your only posting Quranic verses out of context with no relevance to their chronology and calling that a winning argument. I think it would be better to move on to your next point of liking because your clearly out of gas on this one. Shall we?

Your blind obedience to Bukhari & misguided ‘scholars’ never ceases to amaze me. You tell me that I am quoting verses ‘out of context’, yet they are very clear and self explanatory. The bottom line is the Sacred Months are consecutive according to Quran (9:1-5). There is no way around it. They are very, very clear verses. 9:36-37 says those who change alternate the sacred months are the evil ones. The Quran says they are consecutive, Hadiths say they are not. You would have me and everyone on this forum believe that 200 year old hearsay (Bukhari Hadiths) is MORE ACCURATE than GOD’s proven Word, the QURAN?! Your trust in GOD is non-existent if you believe men know better than GOD Almighty.

Your ‘scholars’, through hadiths have altered the sacred months, the Quran says only the disbelievers do this, and yet, here you are quoting questionable hadiths and ‘long standing scholarly’ opinions to justify what the Quran condemns. You can use all the eloquent words and arguments you like, but NOTHING shall abrogate the word of GOD (Quran). If you can justify alternating the sacred months when the Quran clearly condemns it, than you can justify ANYTHING! It does not matter what the Quran says, it is not enough for you. So, debating with you is absolutely useless as your works are adorned in your eyes.