Re: Ghamdi on Hazrat Isa (AS)
To Numb,
If Miracles has to follow the law of Allah, then y call them miracles?
you need some serious studies of Common Sense...
Anyway, back to the topic,
Ghamdi and other scholars have their opinion on certain issues, the tv shows and one page leaf-lets only provide summarized version of the issue, which WE the people love, as it the ambiguity of the issue gives fuel to our imagination.
I'll ask Test001 to quote the part of the posted clips, which he/she found disturbing, it is Ghamdi, a man, who is just another common person, saying what his analysis are, they canbe right and they can be wrong, it does not give anyone any right to call names or abandon all the work done by him.
If i take a Qurani ayat, without its conext, then surely i can prove that there is an order in quran for not to pray, and no one can challenge it. If somebody is putting up idea, which does not goes with the common believe or our understanding of islam, the least we can do is to listen it and analyze it as per quran and hadees.
Always remember at the time, when Prophet (PBUH) announced his Prophecy, he refuted all the existing religion of that time, divine and man-made, he refute all the teaching of other Prophets (AS) we went against the tradtion and denounced all the religions and believes, and then passed what Allah told Him.
I am not comparing anyone, all iam saying, please put all the points together and tell us, what exactly do you want to debate on.
Please no personal attacks, if somebody have nothing to say, and feel like posting anything, please use some other topic.