Re: Genuine Query
^ read ahadith....
sahih bukhari clearly mentions taht the Prophet (saw) said that later people will question the stoning od those found guilty of adultery....
Re: Genuine Query
Sahih Bukhari is a fictional book.
Re: Genuine Query
^ well, maybe it is for u, like there r many who put the Quran in the same category too....
Re: Genuine Query
Would you give precidence to Sahih Bukhari over Quran? Remember, I am not a rejector of Hadeeth. But if hadeeth is against the Quranic teachings, we have to believe that the hadeeth is weak. Because, Anhuzur :saw: couldn’t have done/said anything against Quranic Teachings.
Re: Genuine Query
non muslims will go to hell and they deserve hell
Re: Genuine Query
ramadan must be in the offing.
Really hate to break it to you folks. Adultery and fornication are different things.
Fornication: sex before marriage
Adultery: sex after marriage with anyone other than your spouse
Punishment for fornication: 100 lashes, son
Punishment for adultery: stoning to death.
Rvikz, yes, an adulterous muslim woman will go to paradise eventually after a short stint in hell.
A virtuous infidel will go to hell for not accepting islam.
Its a simple logic: A muslim starts with a A+ in the class, and only loses points when he/she commits sins, wheres a non-muslim starts off with an F-, and doing good deeds in this world doesn’t improve his/her grade point average.
Re: Genuine Query
I will never understand how some (fundamentalists of all religions) believe that God is so merciless that he sends up to 80% of His Creation to Hell, no matter their virtues. That is one cruel God.
Re: Genuine Query
^ that is not cruel...it is just illogical and makes him look like scorned lovuh...
Re: Genuine Query
Don’t even try to understand. Understanding rocket physics is easier.
Is a bad muslim...
....better than a good hindu ?
Re: Is a bad muslim…
did you really just ask that?
Why are you worried about whose better… why not just worry about how good you are.
Re: Is a bad muslim…
You are absolutely right. But, I appreciate if you answer just ‘yes’ or ‘no’.
Re: Is a bad muslim...
Dear sir, you mean bad Muslim with below attitude?
- zina
- drink liquor
- not praying 5 times a day
- not fasting for his whole life
- Murder
- never pay zakat
- scolded his parents
- thieves
- eat pork
- gamble
- using black magic to harm others
Re: Is a bad muslim…
never done that, (i do everything else) so does that make me a good muslim.
Re: Is a bad muslim…
OK, good you asked, the guy I am visulising has done the following:
- not fasting
- not praying except friday
- giving bribes on company behalf and keeping a portion of it
- cutting employees salary for no reason or petty reason
- committing adultry
- taking liquor
- stabing at the back
Re: Is a bad muslim…
Save it. click
Re: Is a bad muslim…
Did you check that list? Murder is on it! 
Re: Is a bad muslim...
Only Allah swt can judge whether the bad "Muslim" with the list of deeds(or missed deeds) is good enough for heaven or not, lets wait for Judegment day :).... as far as Quran tells us, Allah swt will accept "Islam" as the religion.
Re: Is a bad muslim...
A bad muslim is a good kaafir, therefore he is a good hindu.