Re: Fasting on the day of Aashoora (10th Muharram)
The hadith regarding fasting on 10[SUP]th[/SUP] of Muharram. relating it to liberation of Jews from Phraoh under Musa (AS), and thus considering it a happy day, is blatant lie … It is lie, because it is not related to Prophet (SAW) nor is saying of Prophet (SAW) … as Prophet (SAW) could not have said or acted on something that is lie. Whoever concocted this hadith was not only ignorant but thinks that Muslim world is ignorant and thus would accept his lies as truth.
Reasons are many, that shows hadith is concocted lie:
1: Prophet (SAW) migrated to Madina on 1[SUP]st[/SUP] Rabi-ul-Awal (estimated as 15th/16th of June 622 AD) and entered Madina on 16th Rabi-ul-Awal (estimated as 29th/30th June 622 AD).
2: Jews celebrate their freedom from Pharoh under Mosa (AS), happened on 15th, in the month of Nisan (a Jews month that comes around March-April) and they call that event ‘Passover’.
3: The Jew celebrate their freedom on 14/15 of Nisan as ‘Passover’ … and the night of the event is full moon. In 623 AD, month of Nisan started on 8th of March … and 10th Nisan would have been 17th March … though Passover event would have been on 22nd of March. Whereas Muharram must have started around 7th April. 10th Muharram would have been ~ 16th of April … so, dates do not even coincides. Check dates below.
4: Jews months are lunar months (just like Islamic months) … only difference is that, they adjust their lunar year in such a way that it follows solar year … and they do that by adding one month every two to three years. Since 4[SUP]th[/SUP] century (over 200 years before Islam), Jews have fixed this month ‘Nisan’ in March-April … regardless, Nisan is still lunar month and 14/15 of Nisan is always full moon. Their ‘Passover celebration’ lasts for around 7 to 8 days (following 15th Nisan).
Here is detail about Passover (or Pesach) … related to their liberation from pharoh under Mosa (AS).
Passover - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
So, it is impossible that 14/15 of lunar month ‘Nisan’, having full moon night … when Jews got liberated from Pharoh under Mosa (AS) … could be same as 10[SUP]th[/SUP] of lunar month ‘Muharram’ (neither it is possible that 10[SUP]th[/SUP] of Muharram could have night of full moon).
It means, hadith is concocted lies and whoever concocted the lies did not even know or cared about Jews practices. His only purpose, probably on behalf of Ummayad kings, was to fool Muslim masses and make 10[SUP]th[/SUP] of Muharram controversial, and divert attention of Muslims who had love of Prophet (SAW) and wanted to mourn the Shahadah of Prophet (SAW) children in the hands of Ummayad and followers of Ummayad. Only ignorant and those who want to escape from the event of Kerbala, and remembrance of Shahadah, would take this hadith as truth.
5: Ashoora means 10[SUP]th[/SUP] … and every month has its ashoora 10[SUP]th[/SUP], so it is not specific to Muharram, but due to event of Kerbala in Muharram, the name became specifically related to Muharram (and that happened after Kerbala). Controversy that Prophet (SAW) and Quraish used to fast on Ashura before obligatory fasting of Ramadhan, also seems concocted lie. If it was not lie, then hadith that Prophet (SAW) started fasting on 10[SUP]th[/SUP] after seeing Jews fasting and questioning them the reason, shows that until then, Prophet (SAW) did not knew of any significance of 10th Muharram … at least in the eyes of people who concocted the hadith (and Muslims of that time), as, if Prophet (SAW) and Muslims knew of any significance of 10th Muharram, then Prophet (SAW) would not have asked Jews the significance of 10th Muharram, and they (whoever concocted the hadith) would not have concocted the hadith in such way.
So, unless someone prove me wrong by proving with credible evidence that Jews fast on 10th of Muharram for their liberation from Pharoh under Musa (AS), as that is the reason given in hadith for Prophet (SAW) fasting and for Muslims to fast … as far as I am concerned, anyone who fast on 10[SUP]th[/SUP] of Muharram are following lies and since they are doing it considering it as Sunnah [an act prophet (SAW) used to do] then they are doing big sin, associating lies with Prophet (SAW), and for that they would be answerable on judgment day.
Anyhow, if anyone can show that Jews do fast on 10[SUP]th[/SUP] of Muharram considering that as their day of liberation from Pharoh under Musa (AS) … then I would change my statement (with tauba) … though I believe such is impossible for anyone to bring, as Jews are alive religion with recorded history going years before Islam, and they have not left their religious practices … they still celebrate their liberation from Pharoh under the leadership of Musa (AS) … and they call that day, ‘day of Passover’. I do not know if they fast on that day, but if they were fasting due to happiness of their liberation, it would have been on 14/15th of the month ‘Nisan’ and not 10th.
Using Jewish calender record to verify dates:
March 623 Calendar – Israel
[TABLE]
Events
Islamic months
Year 622 AD – 623 AD
Corresponding Jewish months 622 AD – 623 AD
Date ‘Solar Months’
622 AD – 623 AD
Muharram
1 Hijri
Iyar
17 April
622 AD
Safar
Sivan
16 May
prophet (SAW) started journey
Towards Madina (1st R-u-A … 15/16/17 june)
Reached Madina (16[SUP]th[/SUP] R-u-A … 29/30 June/1st July)
Rabi-ul-Awal
1st could be 15, 16 or 17 of June
Tammuz
15 June
622 AD
Rabi-ul-Sani
Av
14 July
Jamad-ul-Awal
Elul
13 Aug
Jamad-ul-Sani
Tishri
11 Sept
Rajab
Heshvan
11 Oct
Shaban
Kislev
10 Nov
Ramadhan
Tevet
10 Dec
Shawal
Shevat
8 Jan
623 AD
Zil-qad
Adar
7 Feb
Zil-Haj
Nisan
(1st month of Jewish year)
8 March
623 AD
1st month of Muharram
Prophet (SAW) in madina
Muharram
2 Hijri
Iyar
7 April
Safar
Sivan
6 may
Date in Jewish month could be same as Islamic month, as Jewish month and Islamic month, both depend on Moon cycle, but occasionally they could vary by a day (in Islam, sighting of Moon is pre-condition for month starting, but I do not think that is true with Jews). Anyhow, Jews month of ‘Nisan’ starts in such a way that night of 15[SUP]th[/SUP] Nisan (night between 14[SUP]th[/SUP] and 15[SUP]th[/SUP] Nisan) is full moon night.
Jews add a month as ‘Adar 2’ every 2 to 3 years … but in 622 AD they did not (as according to Jewish calendar records) … and thus their month of Nisan, the month Jews got their liberation from Pharoh under Musa (AS) … they got their liberation on 15[SUP]th[/SUP] of Nisan … did not even fell in Muharram. Confirms that hadth is concocted.
Note: Though very unlikely, but let assume that the year Prophet (SAW) migrated to Madina, Jewish month of Nisan fell in Muharram following year (assuming that Jews calender record is wrong … though very unlikely), and thus it was observed that some Jews were fasting on 10[SUP]th[/SUP] Muharram … giving reason for hadith to get concocted. But then, we should know that why some Jews may fast on 10[SUP]th[/SUP] of Nisan? … well, even then, hadith is concocted, as fasting is nothing to do with Jews liberation from Pharoh under Musa (AS).
Here is significance of 10[SUP]th[/SUP] Nisan (Jews month): 10th of Nissan is observed by some Jews as a day of fast, in commemoration of Miriam’s demise on that date. She was elder sister of Musa (AS) and Harun (AS). That means, even when some Jews fast on 10th Nisan, they do it not because of happiness, but because of sadness.
So, do not bring this story to prove the point. Anyhow, fast for Miriam’s passing is not commonly observed.
On the other hand, we should remember that Islamic month is moving with solar year and Jews months are almost still. For instance, in Islamic calender, Muharram could be in January or June … or in Jewish month of Nisan or Tammuz …or any month in Jewish calender … that means, no Jews month could correspond to Islamic month of Muharram, hence, it is impossible that Prophet (SAW) would have observed fast relying on past event according to Jewish month and fixed that event on any Islamic month. For instance, Jewish month ‘Nisan’ would always come in March/April every year … but Muharram could come all year round, would make complete cycle (Jan to Dec) over ~33 years.
That means, if Prophet (SAW) wanted to observe fast on 10th of any Jewish month, he could not have linked it with Islamic months, as 10th of any Jewish month could fall in any Islamic month (all 12 months) over the years, and not on any fixed Islamic month … for instance, ‘10th of Nisan’ would fall at one time or another, over the years, in every Islamic month from ‘Muharram’ to ‘Zil-Haj’.