Failing the Baloch

This is one of the most important issues in Pakistan - the Balochistan issue. Does any one care for the Baloch?

http://www.dawn.com/2011/04/12/failing-the-baloch.html

THE mutilated bodies surface quietly in various parts of the province, and usually without any forewarning. The killings take place sporadically but surely, the bodies dumped on unforgiving mountains or on deserted, half-constructed roads. Perhaps they are meant to constitute a message for certain segments of society.
On some occasions, the arms and legs of these corpses are found to have been snapped; often, their faces are smashed in and swollen. At other times, the flesh shows that severe torture was inflicted on various parts of the body, the wounds indicating the use of knives, electric prods or drills that tore gaping holes into the body. The remains are often unrecognisable. And all of them have a gunshot wound in the head.
These aren’t scenes from a battlefield in Afghanistan, Iraq or even the former Yugoslavia. Instead, this is the situation in the largest province in Pakistan: Balochistan. According to assessments made by the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP), severe human rights violations have been taking place in Balochistan since the onset of the latest phase of the insurgency.
Of the many incidents of torture reported by the organisation, one is the case of Alam Pirkani Baloch who belonged to the Pirkani tribe. Apparently, he was arrested and placed in the custody of the Federal Intelligence Unit (FIU). During his incarceration, he was allegedly hung upside down with some sort of sharp-edged tool between his thighs and in his hands.
After his hands and legs had bled for a while, he was taken down. Then chillies and salt were rubbed into his wounds.
In another incident, Ali Beig of the Marri tribe was said to have been arrested by personnel of the City Police Station, Quetta,
and handed over to the FIU. He was made to stand naked in freezing weather, electric shocks were administered to him and he was beaten with strips of rubber. After two months of being in the custody of the Central Investigation Agency (CIA) and the FIU, he was transferred to a jail where the FIU would, allegedly, take him away at night for further torture. After a year, he was once again transferred to the FIU camp where he was subjected to torture with heavy steel rollers.
In another example of the types of activities taking place in Balochistan, Eid Mohammad, son of Haji Wali Jan, was arrested under the Maintenance of Public Order (MPO) Act. He was kept in custody for three months. At the time of his arrest, Eid was a student of class 8 and was only 14 years old at the time. Although details of what that happened to him during his detention are sketchy, it is reported that Eid can no longer go to school. He regularly suffers nightmares, during the course of which he screams hysterically and pleads that he should not be tortured.
These are just a few of the various incidents of alleged torture recorded by the HRCP in its fact-finding missions over the years.
Furthermore — and shockingly — these incidents of torture are not considered separate to and distinct from the instances of disappearances that are taking place in Balochistan.
In fact, many reports pouring in nowadays indicate that most of those desolate and mutilated bodies discovered on the uninhabited mountains or empty roads were actually persons reported as missing. Additionally, suspicion is raised by the fact that many such bodies come to light after there has been an attack on paramilitary or government forces that is blamed on nationalist forces.
Despite the seriousness of the situation in Balochistan, which is indicated by the examples given above, these incidents seem to have raised little concern in other parts of the country. The media appears more concerned about the presence of CIA agents in Pakistan than the actual damage that is being caused apparently by state agents in Balochistan. Meanwhile, the government of Pakistan is more concerned about completing its tenure than actually trying to heal the wounds of the Baloch.
**The Supreme Court, on the other hand, appears more interested in issuing contempt notices to certain PPP leaders **as compared to ensuring the fundamental rights of all those tortured and maimed souls who happen to call Balochistan their home. As for the people of Pakistan, sadly, they appear more interested in scrounging for national pride on the fields of Mohali rather than resurrecting the same on the shamed mountains and empty roads of Balochistan.
However, whatever the motives behind such dismissive attitudes, and civil society and the state authorities’ lack of reaction to such incidents, it is clear that the said acts have served to perhaps irreparably harm any possibility of the Baloch placing their trust in the state of Pakistan and attempting at reconciliation.In fact, it has unfortunately now come to such a head that the hatred that certain Baloch tribal people have long held for the state of Pakistan is seeping into other segments of society.
The educated classes, students as well as other parts of the middle class are all growing increasingly militant.
As stated by Jamil Bugti, son of the late Nawab Akbar, Bugti, “The next generation is all in the mountains, and they’re not willing to talk to anyone. People like me, and others, like the different nationalist parties that are in parliament, they don’t have any role to play. They look very good on TV. That’s about it.”
The writer is a Fulbright scholar and a Karachi based lawyer.

Re: Failing the Baloch

Pakistan need to focus on Balochistan and should invest lot money there butt at the same should also take on these sardars because under these sardars no development can take place

Re: Failing the Baloch

^ That is a myth. As long as control remains with pakistani military, we cannot see much development or patriotism there.

Re: Failing the Baloch

glad to see a report on Balochistan issue that doesn't try to deflect blame to India, Israel, US or Mars

Re: Failing the Baloch

hese unfortunate people have travelled all the way to Islamabad for help

The Express Tribune

Confusion, pain and longing, after they vanished
Published: April 14, 2011

Relatives of Baloch missing persons pin hopes on the SC for recovery.
ISLAMABAD:

It was a painful night for his family when Frontier Corps officials along with security agency personnel entered her house and abducted Sameer.

“My brother was screaming, ‘Baba, help me’ and suddenly his voice vanished,” said Sumiya Abdul Kareem, a resident of Turbat and sister of Sameer Abdul Kareem.

For the past six months, Sameer’s family has been struggling to know where he is. “We do not have a clue. No one is helping us, we are helpless,” she said

At the time of her brother’s abduction, Sumiya was a student of third year, but had to quit her studies due to the sudden change of circumstances.

In another incident of mysterious abduction, Mehlab Baloch, eight, from Balochistan said, “My father was reading books in his office when some people came and took him away. We do not know where he is. I badly miss him.”

While Baloch’s 14-year-old brother had to quit his studies and work as a farmer to earn a livelihood for the family, the void of their missing father haunts them day and night.

Highlighting such tales of agony, a press conference was held on Wednesday by the relatives and family members of Baloch activists who went missing. These people had camped for the last 10 days outside the National Press Club to register their protest and make their voices heard.

Farzana Bibi, sister of a kidnapped Baloch student organisation leader Zakir Majeed said, “The pretense of law and justice being provided to the citizens should be put to rest forever if the Supreme Court does not have the power to demand the immediate recovery of all missing persons.”

The briefing coincided with the SC hearing of the missing person’s case which took place the same day. “All the alleged defenders of the law should be put on trail as it is the security agencies that are abducting thousands of innocents with impunity,” she said.

A representative of Voice for Baloch Missing Person (VBMP) said, “The ball is now in the court of those who claim to be defenders of democracy, to ensure a resolution for the thousands of families who have been suffering incessantly for many years.”

Speaking on the occasion Nasrullah Baloch,VBMP chairperson, said, “This is the second time we have set up a protest camp to project the plight of thousands of Baloch who have been abducted over the past few years.”

“Last year Justice Javed Iqbal gave us assurances that things would improve but instead the situation in Balochistan has deteriorated further,” he said.

He said not only have the kidnappings continued, a new reign of terror had spread throughout the province after mutilated bodies of abducted youth were being recovered on almost a daily basis.

Speaking on the occasion Qadeer Baloch, vice chairman VBMP, said the families of the young men who have been abducted want to know the crimes committed by their loved ones. “They should be charged openly in the court of law and if found guilty, the government has the right to punish them,” he said. “The state is breeding enormous resentment within ordinary Baloch people and creating a fertile ground for separatist movements,” he added.

Published in The Express Tribune, April 14th, 2011

Re: Failing the Baloch

and MQM

Re: Failing the Baloch

But MQM is part of RAW, so why mention it again. It is like saying America and CIA are to blame.. :)

Re: Failing the Baloch

Interesting, a hindu indian passing comments on pakistan's internal affairs. How about answering the massacre that indians have carried out in Kashmir or the exploitation of maoist areas which remain the most backward places in india with the indian govt. taking no interest.... and list goes on.... my advice, keep your nose out of pakistan's internal affairs.

Now coming to the article, it is interesting to note that the article has quite conveniently ignored the fact that thousands of non balochs have been butchered by nationalist balochs backed by the arms, money and training from RAW. Why doesn't the article explain the pain of those families who lost their dear ones to these a__ holes ? These bloody spearatists have made sure that no competent professor or teacher remains in the province by killing most of them and making others flee. Thousands of non-baloch families have migrated from balochistan, yet another achievement of these hindu-backed baloch groups. They have contributed significantly to the death of education in balochistan. Just go and see the condition of schools and colleges and universities in balochistan now. No teacher available.

Moreover, the argument that the pakistani state has neglected the balochs is not quite true. Baloch sardars and hindu-backed baloch separatists are so much against the development in the province that they kill the laborours working on building roads, installing electricity polls or working on creating the port. A tell tale sign that they want the province and common baloch people to remain backward.

Re: Failing the Baloch

^kakaballi is neither hindu nor indian.

Re: Failing the Baloch

LOL! indian (raw) is responsible for the unrest in our province. We don't need to blame you indians, because we already know the real truth.
How pathetic. Just admit it, indians are backing these baloch nationalists. It is a hopeless attempt to destabilize Pakistan, end of story.

I hate articles about Balochistan conflict, because they are always exaggerated damn.

Re: Failing the Baloch

And we should say nothing about injustice with Baluchistan and others.
Great Example.
There are many judges from Baluchistan in our supreme court and no one is Baluch even Pashton of Baluchistan (CJ included)
What the great ...for this
Banay hain ahl e hiwas Mudaee bhi munsaf bhi
Kisay Wakil karain kis say munsafi chahain
بنے ہیں اہل ہوس مدعی بھی منصف بھی
کسے وکیل کریں کس سے منصفی چاہیں

Re: Failing the Baloch

Is there anything we can do to pressurize the Government, Army and other hidden state actors to change the policy and be more just in the dealing with Balochistan?

Re: Failing the Baloch

Keep trying. I am trying it for the sake of Pakistan.
When I saw this thread from you , I was very happy that some one other is too trying. When our Baluch brothers will see it , It will be a clear message for them that they are not alone. We are with them .

Re: Failing the Baloch

                         **"Worse again, he adds, they were supported by India. The  Punjabi general  offers no proof for his claim, but US and British  intelligence broadly  agree, according to the recent WikiLeaks cables.  India sees Balochistan  as payback for Pakistani meddling in Kashmir –  which explains why  Pakistani generals despise the nationalists so much.  "Paid killers,"  says Niazi. He vehemently denies involvement in human  rights violations.  "To us, each and every citizen of Balochistan is  equally dear," he  says."**

Just sayin.

It is as much our fault as anyone else’s but India are definitely part of the problem.

Re: Failing the Baloch

India tries everywhere ,In Baluchistan,Sindh ,KP, Punjab and Kashmir,
But when we give them a chance.
India and others must try if we are not positive to our people.
Why you create MQM,N ,Q,,Junejo League,Haqiqi,Sipah e Sahabh and promote euthenics and religious groups for your purposes to stay more and more in Power.

Re: Failing the Baloch

@rizla86 - you did notice the quote you provided says "...the general offers no proof for his statement". Just like in the wikileaks cable where consulate officials express their opinions!

Everytime somebody in Pak govt has accused India of this nonsense, they claim to have proof and then quick disappear with their tail between their legs.

I am no longer sure if Pakistanis make this claim to frame India or a sop for themselves because they want to be in denial

Re: Failing the Baloch

"US and British intelligence broadly agree.."

Sorry, I think there is a far better chance of them being correct than you.

Re: Failing the Baloch

Yes, Indians and others intervene in Baluchistan, but as Pasha Sb said it is us who provide them opportunity.

If Baluchis were happy being part of Pakistan and being identified as Pakistanis, Indians could do nothing in there. The fact is that a good proportion of Baluchis are not happy and they are justified. We have wronged them for decades and cannot really blame them for being angry about it all. How would you feel if your family members are picked up randomly by 'security forces' on 'suspicion' and sometimes never returned? We lost West Pakistan through similar blunders and we are doing it again.

The reports about Baluchistan are not exaggerated. I have personally witnessed Pakistan military personnel needing armed escort every time they leave their units even in some urban areas. I have also seen extreme poverty around Gawadar while the elite from Punjab and Sindh were cutting land deals in the imposing imperialistic building of Pearl Continental hotel there. About time we realize what we have done and try to undone it.

Re: Failing the Baloch

I agree with snowy_winter :)

It's really funny when indians deny involvement with the Balochistan Liberation Army and others.

Well, I think it's a bit exaggerated. You can't lump all Pakistani balochi together. There are separatist movements, but not every balochi feels hatred for Pakistan.
Our biggest problem is the puppet government. They only invest in Punjab and Sindh, now who will invest in other parts in Pakistan? Nobody. They treat them like second-class citizens, so obviously people will support an azad balochistan right?
You might remember the Reko Diq issue. Balochistan province is extremely rich in minerals and natural resources. I can understand their fear. It's their land and foreigners will take away all it's richdom, BUT it will not benefit any balochi.

And then the Gwadar problem. It's well known that the region (middle east/iran/india) is against vision of Gwadar, and they support the separatist. Pakistan's strategic location as a gateway to Central Asia would definitely benefit Pakistan and change it's fate. But again, other countries try to break Pakistan.

Our fellow Pakistani balochi feel like second-class citizens in their own country! Balochi landlords are trying to create chaos in Pakistan by killing innocent non-balochi people, with help from *******s outside our country. These landlors try to keep poor balochi people poor. So what can we do now to save our beloved Pakistan...

I will never support any army operation in Balochistan because I don't believe in any military solution. It will make them even more angry.
Our army is to protect our people, not to fight against them.
Recently, the Pak Army is building schools in Balochistan and providing education to poor balochi youth. A nice gesture..

Re: Failing the Baloch

Many elite Pashtuns and Baloch are also cutting deals in the imperialistic PC Hotel. I have been to Gwadar and even today the people there are peaceful. it is one of the few areas of Balochistan where you could be gauranteed peace. The people of Gwadar have no problems with development - it is the Baloch from the inner areas causing the problems. Gwadar has seen a lot of change in the last 10 years. They have no one but Musharaf and his government to thank for that. The people can now sell any products they catch in Karachi - before it would take a few days to travel but now just 12 hours. Fishermen have done fairly well.