Re: Eid milad un nabi is biddat - Saudi mufti
No
… but I don’t know how that is going to help you arrive at an understanding of my position; What it might do is rig the situation to make it seem like a problem in my approach. I would also say that those who do not celebrate it as an event today are not wrong for not doing so either. However, I believe it is not wrong for celebrating it … because there is a reason why they/we celebrate it.
If I undermine the Sahabah (RA) in any way I have no leg to stand on …
Please next time if you ask a question that you want a yes or no answer for … don’t phrase it like this:
“Have you always been an idiot?”
Because then if I answer yes I am an idiot and if I answer no I am still an idiot. Next time give me some room to qualify myself.