Re: Eid milad un nabi is biddat - Saudi mufti
I am as well placed as anyone else on the forum to speak, and my right is what they are using as their right. I can highlight what i think is kufr, i can say what I have been taught and believe in to be kufr, I can say I believe such and such position is deviant..and so on.
Also I do have indicators that my involvement has had a beneficial impact on some of the posters, be it an unwelcome, unwanted, not liked impact.
You are welcome to re-ignite our talk [from where we left off], or wait for Ibn sadique to do the talking for you, as I’m sure he will not allow me to say something which is incorrect. Silence in Islam can be taken as approval
Its kinda feels right to be bullying ahul bidah positions even after all they have put in of effort to cement their positions in the minds of people, and to use their language Bidaaat, deviant, Bidaatti, Kafir, KUFR, Mushrik,…its like sweet justice
Not everything is provable to another person. He who is destined to be a kafir, for example, can not be helped.
In order for you to say I have failed to prove an issue to you, you must carry on talking to me for a sufficient period of time [which would be years, or more then our lifetimes in some cases]
And btw I do not claim that I can prove to you. I can claim I can prove such and such position as being Islamic. There is a difference. The matter can be settled, perhaps i can take you to the pond, perhaps you wont drink.
The Mawlid Shareef debate can be resolved
up to you
This conversation is not really worth it because you have given up the subject so now you sound like you just want to score a point against me personally. Dude that is not a big feat, set your goals higher