Re: Dr. Zakir Naik refers to Muhammad S.A.W....
@Khamosh Girl;
First of all, I am writing these lines not to prove that I am right. Just looking forward for healthy Knowledge sharing over islam. I might be wrong and if i am Wrong then I am all looking forward for +ve knowledge that is going to be shared here.
Now, lets come to the topic. I will first reply to your messages one by one.
1: You posted some videos of Tahir-ul-qadri on specific topic. I accept him as a great scholar (accept on few controversial things). Now, my reply to those videos will be the same as i posted about. Leme paste it here
[quote]
I would like to refer you to the speech that Abubakr R.A did on the death of Prophet Muhammad S.A.W. When everyone was in grief. He said that .. Everyone who used to worship prophet muhammad s.a.w listen carefully, he is not among us anymore. But if you worship Allah, then you don't have to worry. Allah is always here and will here.
[/quote]
Now, this quote from Hazrat Abubakar is authentic and could be referred from hadiths books. Secondly, we don't have a single objection on the personality of Hazrat Abubakar. Now its your choice, are you gona believe on the "manipulated" words of Tahir-ul-qadri or Hazrat Abu bakar R.A
-- Tahir-ul-qadri sahab to 12 Rabi-ul-Awal ko b bohat ahtmam say manatay hain. Aap hadeeths ki 6 books mai kahi say b koi reference la dain jaha 12 rabi-ul-awal ka zikar aur is ki ahmiat byaan ho.
2: Related to quranic verses that you posted
[quote]
Quran says..."And call not those who are slain in the way of Allah dead, Nay they are living, only you perceive not"
[/quote]
Could you please tell me the name of sura and could you also narrate the translation of 3 ayats before this particular ayat and 3 ayat after this particular aya. I want to see if this particular ayat and the context before these ayat is actually referring Prophet S.A.W or these ayat are referring to the importance of Jihad and the greatness of the people who die for Allah.
3: Sure, We are not that much capable of discussing Hazrat Muhammad S.A.W. However, if we are discussing something related to islam, or related to islamic knowledge then we must share whatever we can.
4: I am not going to satisfy you on the fact that Hazrat Muhammad S.A.W is dead. That would be your personal decision, I am just going to refer few points.
There is another hadeeth which i am not able to recall properly but it states something like that Rasool Pak s.a.w descend down to reply to the person who send darood shareef on them. *** I AM NOT SURE ABOUT THIS HADEETH BUT IT HAS SOME MEANINGS LIKE THAT ***. God forbid me if i am wrong
A note on sub-continent muslims
There is one particular fact that we (sub-continent) muslims have to realize that we are descendants of Hindus. At some point of our ancestor tree, they were hindu. So, we still have those kind a gene. We still love to worship or praise those things which are not even listed in our religion.
- Things like doing sajda on mazaar - those muslims justify it as their "aqeedat" to those buzurg.
- Things like relating some arbitrary thing to religion - shape of cloud, shape of pakistan's map etc (you better know what i am talking about).
The list goes on.
My question is, Why all these things are in sub-continent muslims. Why muslims of other countries don't believe in these?
A bottom line: As long as something is in Quran and Hadeeth it is acceptable. No sooner, the words are manipulated by mula's that we have now a days .. I have doubts :)
ne haath utha kr ungli se 3 martaba ishara farmaya or 3 martaba yeh farmaya "Bal Alrafeeq Al A’aala" (ab koi nahi**) Balke woh bara rafeeq chahiyeh**". Yehi alfaaz zuban-e-aqds pr thy k naguhan magds haath latak gay or aankhain chat ki taraf dekhtay howay khuli reh gai or App 