What do you guys think about the division of Sind.
New Province # 1 (jinnah pur) : Karachi, Hyderabad, Thar parkar, badin, thatta
New Province # 2 (sindh) : dadu, nawabshah, sanghar, khair pur
New Province # 3 (could merge with newly seriki provice from northern punjab): larkana, sakkhar, shikarpur, jacobabad.
feel free to suggest/share any other good combination.
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
YES. We need more administrative units all over Pakistan. It will not be a division of sindh or division of Punjab or some other province. It will be a creation of administrative units.
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
YES. We need more administrative units all over Pakistan. It will not be a division of sindh or division of Punjab or some other province. It will be a creation of administrative units.
yes, it is surely division of administrative unit.
and if it is successful, then same rule of division could be implemented in other provinces of pakistan.
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
Here in USA, a redneck can move to the yankee land but he/she needs to get the State ID or Driv. Lisc of that state within few weeks as its against the law otherwise. This is what Pakistan needs to do. It may not matter how many provinces, but every province should issue its own National ID card so the person feels like part of that province even if he/she moved from different part of the country. I could be urdu speaking but if I am living in "Saraiki province" I belong to that area of Pakistan and not Karachi. If I am going to invest in the properties and/or business of another province, I should pay 'out of province tax' to that provincial govt. That way every province would feel compensated for the investors who are taking advantage of the infrastructure of that province. Baluchistan is not going to feel neglected, if the pertol pumps in Quetta that are owned by the waderas of sindh are generating extra revenue for Baluchistan.
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
What do you guys think about the division of Sind.
New Province # 1 (jinnah pur) : Karachi, Hyderabad, Thar parkar, badin, thatta
New Province # 2 (sindh) : dadu, nawabshah, sanghar, khair pur
New Province # 3 (could merge with newly seriki provice from northern punjab): larkana, sakkhar, shikarpur, jacobabad.
feel free to suggest/share any other good combination.
Any particular basis and reasoning for these combinations.
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
What stakeholders say about Division of Sindh
http://www.dawn.com/2011/08/09/anp-wont-accept-division-of-sindh.html
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
Any particular basis and reasoning for these combinations.
only basis is to make them more manageable in term of administration point of view.
I would also suggest that security, policing, land marking, zoning, safety, driver licensing should be issued and provided by province.
defenc, printing money, creating armies, and foreign affair should be controlled by islamabad.
it think, it is best solution and good balance of powers.
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
Any particular basis and reasoning for these combinations.
Cultural & Heritage influence.
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
only basis is to make them more manageable in term of administration point of view.
I would also suggest that security, policing, land marking, zoning, safety, driver licensing should be issued and provided by province.
defenc, printing money, creating armies, and foreign affair should be controlled by islamabad.
it think, it is best solution and good balance of powers.
No we don't need division of Sindh. Karachi is the problem, divide this city in to five cities and let every one live in peace. Revive old local government system as very recently apporved by PA.
Yeh tumhara khwab jinah pur wala kabhi nahin pura hoga. us kay leay tumahain local Sindhis, Punjabis, Pukhtoons and Baluchis sub ko qatal karna parhayga sumjhay. Nonsense divide Sindh!
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
Cultural & Heritage influence.
Explain Plz.
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
only basis is to make them more manageable in term of administration point of view.
I would also suggest that security, policing, land marking, zoning, safety, driver licensing should be issued and provided by province.
defenc, printing money, creating armies, and foreign affair should be controlled by islamabad.
it think, it is best solution and good balance of powers.
You are telling about empowerment and transferring of powers to provinces. Can't these things be done without dividing the existing province.
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
Explain Plz.
Yaar please yeah tum nunnay munnay bachchay srif mere hee post ke reply main kyun bun jaatay ho? Why people are demanding Hazara and Multan in separate provinces? Its language and cultural influence that is different than rest of punjab and pakhtoonkhwah. Sindh Urban tou unofficially treated as a separate province from the day one. Now if someone is suggesting an actual dividing line tou is main konsa azaab ho gayaa.
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
Although I dont support his ‘suggested’ provinces, he has a reasoning for why he want more provinces. On the other hand, you replay is only lacking Quran in your hand else you sounded just like ZM. Emotional blackmailing at its best :k:
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
No we don't need division of Sindh.
Yeh tumhara khwab jinah pur wala kabhi nahin pura hoga.!
achcha lets not divide sindh lekin jo hissay balochistan aur punjab ke thay, wo oon ko wapis ker detay hain.
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
Yaar please yeah tum nunnay munnay bachchay srif mere hee post ke reply main kyun bun jaatay ho? Why people are demanding Hazara and Multan in separate provinces? Its language and cultural influence that is different than rest of punjab and pakhtoonkhwah. Sindh Urban tou unofficially treated as a separate province from the day one. Now if someone is suggesting an actual dividing line tou is main konsa azaab ho gayaa.
What are talking man? OP said it should be divided for administrative purposes and you are saying that different in culture. BTW, can you tell me different in language spoken in Hyderabad, Larkana, Dadu, Sukkur, Shikarpur,Jaccobabad, Thatta, Tharparkar?
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
Really I am sick of repeatedly hearing nonsense of division of Sindh on ethinic basis. We need brotherhood and harmony among different cummunities, not further polarization what this mqm kid is suggesting. This kind of fitna will never stop, kub tak batwara kartay rahogay?
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
What are talking man? OP said it should be divided for administrative purposes and you are saying that different in culture. BTW, can you tell me different in language spoken in Hyderabad, Larkana, Dadu, Sukkur, Shikarpur,Jaccobabad, Thatta, Tharparkar?
OP was just being politically correct. :D
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
achcha lets not divide sindh lekin jo hissay balochistan aur punjab ke thay, wo oon ko wapis ker detay hain.
Which parts?
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
OP was just being politically correct. :D
can you tell me different in language spoken in Hyderabad, Larkana, Dadu, Sukkur, Shikarpur,Jaccobabad, Thatta, Tharparkar?
Re: Division of Sind : New provinces
Really I am sick of repeatedly hearing nonsense of division of Sindh on ethinic basis. We need brotherhood and harmony among different cummunities, not further polarization what this mqm kid is suggesting. This kind of fitna will never stop, kub tak batwara kartay rahogay?
I am clueless why administrative units are seen as 'batwara'. Its known universal facts that small administrative units are mostly well managed where power is given to locals and not controlled by someone sitting 100s/10000s miles away in Governor house or CM house.