Distinction between Medicine and Governance/Banking in Muslim societies

[ravage]

Re: Distinction between Medicine and Governance/Banking in Muslim societies

@shardmanny

islam is a complete way of life, theres been nothing mentioned or hinted in this thread that would change this fact

the minorities (belonging to sects) are more prone to this line of attack.

basically this thread is a reworked ai (anti islamic) christian allegation that islam is not complete. on here it is mixed with a few well known concepts of falsehood. the christians were intelligent enough to avoid this and did not delve into specifics

anyway here is a summary of it

please dont take too much notice of how they are trying to portray our belief

Wah. So your allegation is that I read this christian website and then reworked it using my own experiences with the same purposes as those of this anti-christian site. Paranoid much?

This is the overuse of persecution and the world is out to get me talk that dilutes genuine victimization. Trust me, IF I am even inspired by any other source, I would cite it. Thats part of my deen, and I have many more years of posting history than you on this very website to back that up.

since the allegation is on our beliefs we all know our Prophet SAW lived a complete way of life but lets leave the Prophet SAW and the Sahaba RAWA ( RAWA = Allah SWT is well-pleased with them and they are well-pleased with Him)
modern (not modren) examples can be shown by asking yourself 'can a muslim, starting with no money in his pocket or food to eat go a whole day conducting himself in the islamic way? of course he can. for two days? a year? for longer? this person lives the complete islamic way of life

can anyone in the permissable professions go a whole day in the islamic way? yes he can

what if this makes muslims less competetive in the marketplace? if it does then it does (but i know muslims would fare very well in many industries due to superior ethics) as muslims we believe Allah SWT and only Allah Subhanahu provides sustenence.

societies rejecting islam
is it possible for all of humanity to reject islam or for islam to be wiped out? NO
is it possible for non muslims to reject islam? YES
is it possible for muslim societies to partially reject/avoid islam? YES
is it possible for muslims to wholly (complete way of life) accept and live islam? YES

So this is the substantive part of your post. You are asserting positively that comprehensive means comprehensive, and say that its possible to follow that way of life even if it may disadvantage you in certain professions. Fair enough. That is not an unusual opinion IMO, The Amish, the Luddites all took similar positions even on the christian side (suggesting that one answer to the christian article you posted is to tell them that this rhetoric exists on their side as well).

But whats interesting to me are the implications of what you’re saying above and in the text you posted. You say comprehensive means comprehensive and people who seek any other ‘deen’ are going to hell. Does that mean that otherwise devout Muslims who follow the ‘deen’ of any particular profession, ‘deen’ (codes of conduct) derived secularly i.e. through consensus on disparate origins and religious/areligious/athiest formulators, for instance doctors/lawyers/auditors etc, are going to Hell because they choose to do follow it?