Details of interpreting verses from the Qur'an and obvious blunders

Ibn_Sadique · September 6, 2012, 11:33pm

Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders

I don’t understand why you guys have problem with the statement ? What is Quran. It is the word of Allah and protected by Him so what is in it is above board. Who is the mahdi and messiah? Divinely guided one as every prophet was a Mahdi. He was supposed to be a ‘HAKAM’ (one who will give verdict in the matters of conflict) and of course he will not be simply applying his logic and understanding but he will be a Mahdi who will receive correct understanding of different issues and who will do wahi on him. Of course Allah. Sayings of the holy prophet(pbuh) are very sacred to us if we are sure that they came from his mouth since they cannot go against Quran. Can we be sure of ahadith on the same level that we are sure of Quran. No. why not? Because ahadith are not promised protection by Allah. That is why Muhadeseen went through painstaking process before they included them in their books. What did they do to other ahadith ? threw them like waste paper . right? Their effort is great and commendable and we hold them in high respect but can we say that their efforts are beyond error? And if the ‘Hakam’, based on instruction from Allah, cannot tell us what is right and what is not. then what is he called ‘Hakam’ for?

Muhadeseen have done the job, they have sorted the ahadith and have graded them.

Nobody disputes the sahih ahadith – As it was human effort one can allow for .01% error is authentic ahadith.

Islam is based on Quran and Sunnah and authentic ahadith is source of Sunnah of the Blessed Prophet (saw).

MGAQ had an agenda – We don’t care what he did – we have issue with his claim being Messiah and Mahdi.

Once we taken him to be FALSE AND AN IMPOSTER – everything from him is misguidance par excellence.

Agreed – Dispute lies between True Mahdi/Messiah and wannabes/impostors/ charlatans

I am sure you’ll agree with me that wannabes/impostors/ charlatans are not to be followed.