Details of interpreting verses from the Qur'an and obvious blunders

[Mr.Popat]

Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders

@psyah

The raising of spiritually dead people is a poor interpretation. The Qur’an uses the words guidance and misguidance for that … There is no reason to use metaphors here. Secondly, none of the companions interpreted this raising as a metaphor … Thirdly, it is impossible to conceptualise how "raising of spiritually dead people is undertaken" if it is a sudden magical turn of the state of disbelief in to belief then this goes against what Mr.Popat was arguing about before … That when Isa (AS) returns people will see him and convert … He said this is an injustice that people are made to convert and he wrongfully cited the verses of “no compulsion …” … But here he is saying that this is what raising of spiritually dead people is exactly … It is a magical conversion … This is his inconsistency …

Its time you open the Holy Quran and see for yourself what words Allah uses.

27-80 Verily, thou canst not make the dead to hear, nor canst thou make the deaf to hear the call, when they turn back retreating.

30-52 And thou** canst not make the dead to hear**, nor canst thou make the deaf to hear the call, when they turn away showing their backs.

35-22 Nor alike are the living and the dead. Surely, Allah causes him to hear whom He pleases; and thou canst not make those to hear who are in the graves.

2-18 They are deaf, dumb and blind; so they will not return

Whose deaf , dumb and blind ? Were Makkans deaf, dumb and blind ? what does that tell you ? :halo:

Allah alone will raise dead :

2-154 And say not of those who are killed in the cause of Allah that they are dead; nay, they are living; only you perceive not

Try to understand what I’m showing you. The difference between a physical body living and physical body dead. Physical body which is alive is called dead by Allah, and physical body which is dead is called alive by Allah.

The reverse is actually true. Companions did not interpret ‘raising of dead’ as literal raising of dead. They knew in which context the word ‘dead’ is used. (see above verses).

You are falsely accusing me. He a.s raised spiritual dead by Allah’s leave. Then in another verse of Quran Allah says, it is up to him whomsoever he show the right path. The believers have to struggle after being spiritually raised. The prophet of Allah who spiritually raised people was Jesus a.s. Who ever accepts Him is spiritually raised and not dead anymore. Whosoever does not, this is what Allah says :

6-36 Only those can accept who listen. And as for the dead, Allah will raise them to life, then to Him shall they be brought back.

who continue to disbelieve and die spiritually dead, allah will raise them again and their account will be with Allah. Please open your eyes! Read Quran! Don’t find flaws in Allah’s book. Synchronize what ahadith says with that of what Qur’an says and then make a belief.

There is no inconsistency you’ll see from my side inshAllah. I have alhamdulillah lots and lots of proof to back up what I believe. I not only write something for the sake of it but provide verses of Qur’an. Something that I dont see often from your side.

ps: even then.. ill save you some time. You wont be able to answer all this. What strange is that you are using his miracles as an argument that he a.s is in heaven alive. Silly and poor argumentation.