You did not read my question in full. I asked
There was a reason I asked if He a.s literally raised the dead, there must be some evidence from jewish books or any evidence from any book confirming this. But we find none.
I know about the verse which you’re talking about.
Do you know in Qur’an ‘dead’ is also described as one who is spiritually dead?
Do you know birds are described as the ones who accept the truth and will come flying to their master even if the master is far off from them?
Do you know blinds in Quran are described as the ones who are spiritually blind ?
What is it that prophet do without the ‘will of God’ ? Everything they do is by the ‘will of God’. Jesus a.s raised spiritually dead, cured spiritually blind people and breathe the spirit in birds.
Only God alone does all this ‘literally’. What Isa a.s have done is the responsibility of a prophet. To bring people to the true path.
I see you copying this ayaah so many times. I don’t have any perversity in my heart. I have mohkam verses of Quran.. and I interpret allegorical verses in accordance to the mohkam verses of Quran. I don’t need to rely on any misleading belief which contradict mohkam verses of Quran. The denying part is from your side. You call anything miracle if your belief goes against the mohkam verses of Quran. You are the one who seek refuge is allegorical verses of Quran.
I’ll give you example. Quran says all prophets were men. They all require food. Quran says you are to live and die on this Earth. Quran says Allah doesnt eat food and therefore dont require food to remain alive. What do you do ? You go against all these verses to suit your agenda!. You go against them all and surprisingly call it a miracle not thinking for once that you’re going against Qur’an. There are many examples like this. But ill stop here. Kindly look at your arguments and then read the verse you posted above.
Oh bhai mere.. that’s what i’m saying ! All prophets perform tasks by Allah’s leave. There are 2 meanings of dead in Quran. One who is spiritually dead, and one who is literally dead. One who is DEAD literally does NOT come back to life. Whose spiritually dead, prophets raise them alive by Allah’s leave.. by showing them truth. Allah is the ONLY one who will raise people who are dead on the day of judgement. There was a reason why i asked if any jew believed in Jesus after he raised dead? any instance you find where the dead raised told about his experience as being dead. Why such stubbornness ?
Read this verse .. 27:80 Verily, thou canst not make the dead to hear, nor canst thou make the deaf to hear the call, when they turn back retreating. ( see 30:52 , 35:22 as well )
Referring to people who are spiritually dead. Or else, we know dead people dont hear. We know Muhammad PBUH was not sent as a messenger to dead people literally.
This is what Allah says about himself. Now this is speaking of literally.
36:12 Surely, We alone give life to the dead, and We record that which they send forward and that which they leave behind; and all things have We recorded in a clear Book.
One may argue that it may mean spiritually too, through messenger, but if you read the whole verse, its talking about when one literally dies and send forward his deeds..
**16:38 **And they swear by Allah their strongest oaths, that Allah will not raise up those who die. Nay, He will certainly raise them up — a promise He has made binding on Himself, but most people know not.
Choice is yours. You need to see where the term dead means what. Allah will raise ‘dead’ literally on day of judgement. Allah does not send back to Earth someone who is dead. Jesus a.s as a messenger raised spiritually dead, cured spiritually blind, ofcourse by Allah’s leave. Nothing a prophet does without His leave. But He a.s cannot perform such things which Allah says only he is capable of doing.
**
We dont see people believing in prophets when they show any miracle. Prophets are not sent to Earth to perform different kind of magical tricks. Those who are pious and God fearing demands no miracle from prophets. Abu Bakr r.a is an example.
Though I believe splitting of moon was a kashf but for argument sake, the miracle of Muhammad PBUH is different than Isa a.s. Muhammad PBUH didnt do something which Allah says only he does. Whereas, to you, Isa a.s did stuff which Allah says only he will do.
that is again your claim. You are welcome to keep claiming whatever you like. I’m interested in evidence that back up the claim. You are following Islam exactly how companions have understood it? ok.. if that makes you happy. Allah has promised to keep Quran intact and the words in it intact. Ahadith were compiled some 200 years after Muhammad PBUH death. There is a fair amount of chance that when Isa a.s comes, he will tell you where you’ve been wrong. But even then, you will actually reject prophet of Allah for the mere reason that he does not have the authority to tell you what true Islam is simply because Islam that you understood is exactly how companions understood it (which again is just a claim ).
Where will the verse of Quran go that says Jesus is alive in heavens, when Jesus a.s actually returns ? Will you take away that verse ? do you believe Quran to be a book that has an expiry date ?
Question again is.. why will he not be able to raise dead and cure blind in his second coming ? If he a.s is the same prophet… why wont he be able to do it again ? 