Details of interpreting verses from the Qur'an and obvious blunders

[psyah]

Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders

@Mr.Popat

If verse allows exception then these questions are raised :

1. ‘therein shall you live’ >> exception : there are chances people CAN live outside the Earth.
2. ‘therein shall you die’ >> exception : People do die in space too.
3. ‘therein shall you be brought forth’ >>exception : Allah can brought forth from anywhere.

apply these exceptions on Isa a.s ..

1)>> i dont know how you would answer if a person is alive and is living outside the Earth
2)>> if people do die in space, then He a.s must be dead since he is somewhere other than Earth.
3)>> if Allah can brought forth from anywhere, then why does Isa a.s have to come to Earth and die and be brought forth from here? why can he not be brought forth from anywhere ? The fact that you DO believe Isa a.s to come ON Earth to die, the fact that you DO believe that he a.s will be brought forth from Earth ( agreeing to 2 of the points of the verse ) , then you must also believe that in order for him to be alive, he must be on Earth.. or else anywhere he must be, he a.s must be dead.

Kindly think about it.

Answer 1 - Allah does as He Wills

2. please explain this to me … The reasoning in your argument seems disjointed from your argument’s conclusion. How did you conclude Isa (AS) MUST be dead, from the idea that people CAN die in space? You have forgotten 1) above … Where people can also LIVE in space as well as DIE in it. And space is only an example.

3. he (AS) does not have to come to Earth for that reason … For Isa (AS) … His life has been mapped out for us in the signs of the end times … And from these we draw conclusions such as … Isa (AS) being buried in Madinah … Next to our dear prophet Muhammad (SAW) …