Details of interpreting verses from the Qur'an and obvious blunders

[Mr.Popat]

Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders

@psyah

Peace Mr.Popat

Ok ok … I’ll calm down …

Now I have highlighted part of your text above … Show in the ‘first part’ of that verse where it says “he passed away like others” ???

I need to see how you are making the “qad khalat” of previous prophets = the predicament of “Isa (AS)” …

You said earlier that Isa a.s is like other prophets not because he passed away like others but because he ate like others. This is not right. The reason why is :

1. In the verse, only Jesus a.s and virgin Mary (a.s) is mentioned as the one who used to eat.
2. Jesus a.s is mentioned as a messenger, like messengers before Him.
3. Jesus a.s is not like other messengers because they all ate. This is not the likeness the verse is presenting. If you think this is the case, then how is it that all prophets stopped eating and died, whereas, Jesus a.s is not eating and is still alive. There is no comparison of Jesus a.s with other prophets in regards to example of eating.

@psyah

A verse can contain many sentences … The first part that you are alluding to has two sentences:

a) Isa (AS) is a messenger
b) Messengers have passed away before him

Where in these two sentences does it say that Isa (AS) has:

1. Passed Away
2. He is like them or his passing away was like theirs?

Isa a.s is a messenger. Messengers have passed away before him. Does it mean messengers before him have passed away but Isa a.s has not? What was the point of Allah saying He was no more than a messenger ? who is taking him anything other than a messenger?

(let’s make this example similar to that of the verse). Henry is no more than a human. Humans make mistake. Does it mean humans make mistake but Henry does not ? If this is the case, then Henry is someone more than a human. It’s simple logic. How can you call this a poor logic ?

2. Either His passing away was like other prophets, or other prophets passing away was like His. As I said, either..or…

Note: You cannot split verses up in to parts - this particular verse has at least 4 sentences and each one of those sentences are intertwined. If you separate them in to two parts you will get an absurdity that I will show you in short while inshaAllah.

You know I’ve addressed about the example of eating in that verse. It is only about Jesus and His mother. How does the example of eating for Jesus a.s and His mother in any way related to prophets who passed away before Jesus a.s ?

Let me show you the Venn diagram of the logical construct of this verse 5:75 … Please show me how I have made it incorrectly.

I will comment on this later on, iA