Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders
Peace Mr.Popat
The clause of the verse is not found mid-sentence … You are making it out that the phrase Qad Khalat is in any way saying “death” … And on top of that you are being deceptive with the mid- sentence break … According to me Isa (AS) has “come and gone” Qad Khalat applies to him (AS) … But just because messengers like him (AS) have come and gone, it does not mean they have “come and gone” in the same way as him (AS) …
And if some of them have ascended to heaven … I can’t affirm that or reject that since there are 123,950 odd prophets that I do not have any information on and neither do you.
Otherwise there are examples of prophetic Ascension other than Isa (AS) …
Sayyiduna Idris (AS) was one candidate …he (AS) is known as Enoch … See