psyah
August 23, 2012, 10:32pm
405
Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders
Man, its you who’ve got very poor logic skills..Seriously, it makes me laugh! ..You just dont want to admit whats clearly the teaching of Qur’an.
You are implying that there are ‘some’ humans that dont make mistakes. Because Henry is a human and “NOT ALL” humans make mistakes, therefore Henry is an exception ! Really buddy… really ?? It’s a given thing that humans which include everyone make mistakes!
**
Both verses have qad khalat. Lets take Isa a.s’s case. If 'ALL" prophets did not pass away before Isa a.s, then there should be someone who must be alive before Isa a.s. Who are the prophets who are still alive before Isa a.s ?
“come and gone” is used for prophets before Muhammad PBUH and before Isa a.s. You are wrong to say that in one verse ‘come and gone’ are explained by ‘to eat’. This is my 100th time telling you, the example of eating is the 2nd part of that verse. It is only about Jesus a.s and His Virgin Mother Mary. The first part of the verse is the same as what the verse of Muhammad PBUH says.. prophets before him have passed away. Part 2 of 5:75 about eating is to show Christians that He ate, but God does not eat. The first part of 5:75 is clear enough. It is very unfair from your side to be purposely ignoring part 1 of verse 5:75, which says Isa a.s was a messenger like others and messengers like him have passed away. No, passing away is not described in this verse as someone who ate. Kindly get that right.
No. There is no other way of someone passing away from this world. Once you are alive, you do not go to heaven unless you die. To say that mawt is the only term to be used for death is non sense! Verse 2:134, 2:141, 13:30 and other verses in which Qad khalat has been used to mean death/dead. There are also other verses in which translators have translated the terms as passed away to mean they died. To say ‘passed away’ mean ‘came and gone’ and not explaining how you take ‘came and gone’ shows you are deliberately choosing not to talk about it.
He died, but not by getting killed, but rather from a natural death. Thats the only 2 ways. Since Quran clears him that He did not die from crucifixion(killed), the other way and only way is to die from a natural death.
Jesus a.s according to you is being sustained some other way. If you believe this then you are not taking him as a prophet, neither are you taking him as a human nauzubillah. He is alive according to you, and he is alive without food. The attribute Allah said is for himself. Do you really see this as a small thing ?
Thats a good conclusion to satisfy your own mind. However, Quran tells us something else. We should have our beliefs in accordance to Quran, not have Quran interpreted in accordance to our beliefs.
Mr.Popat
I don’t want to become an Ahmadi … And you obviously don’t want to leave being an Ahmadi … Let’s agree to disagree about our interpretations … Because we are going around in circles …
This latest post of yours is evidence of more distractions for me to entertain … Leave me alone or stick to the topic.