psyah
August 18, 2012, 1:11am
376
Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders
We are talking about prophets here. Do you know of any prophet sent to mankind who was jinn ? Angels and jinn is out of the question here. They are not worshiped. Jesus a.s is worshiped as God. All prophets sent to mankind were 1 ) men 2) were bound to human needs.
Jinns and angels have different life form. Had they been worshiped, Allah would have compared himself with them too. But the verse in comparing Jesus a.s who was a human with God himself. Eating is an attribute limited to all living creatures on earth who are bound to die. Your reasoning is poor.. and so are your questions.
Allah says prophets require food to sustain themselves ! You are telling me Allah can sustain in any way he wills. Yes, but then whoever he sustain without food can not be considered a human being and/or a messenger. They HAVE to eat. Eating is their requirement. I’m showing you verse. Allah says we did not create their bodies that required no food. What does that tell you? It shows us they were like us.. it shows us they needed food, and since food is associated with humans in the verse, humans who does not require food are either 1) dead, or 2) not humans at all, but rather some other creature… perhaps jinns or angels, (since they do not eat , but surely not humans).
:S i’m sorry, what ?
I do not associate anyone with Allah. Not by tongue, and not by any kind of beliefs. I dont know what was your reasoning of talking about Dajjal here. Leave it up to me what i will do when Dajjal comes. Dont just assume what i’ll do.
yeah. Verse about Muhammad PBUH, prophets before him have been told to passed away by either getting killed or by dying a natural death. Keep in mind, Muhammad PBUH is not called upon beside Allah. Jesus a.s’s case, eating was specifically mentioned to show that humans who are mortals cannot be called God because they eat and die . God does not eat and does not die.
Look in to the history of your prophets who have come and gone. Also mention how Allah is explaining the ‘come and gone’ in the verse of Muhammad PBUH. 1) by getting killed 2) by dying a natural death. No other way of coming and going is mentioned. If Jesus a.s is an exception in this verse, then look at the verse about Jesus a.s
Passed away term is used in that too. Prophets like him have passed away before him. We know all prophets before Jesus a.s died. Honestly, where’s the rocket science in this.
You are arguing unnecessarily.
Please don’t ask me if I know of any Jinn sent to mankind as a prophet again … when you hold that Jinn are naughty human lads …
Regarding the Attributes of Divinity - when I wrote it earlier I was half asleep … I meant to say you are so easily swayed by certain simple things as being Divine Attributes that if you were to see Dajjal you would be unable to work out whether his claims of Divinity are true or not …
You are still singing the same tune regarding Qad Khalat - I’ve highlighted in red the part that you cannot explain from the verse … The only thing in that verse that is said about Isa (AS) is his eating … nothing else … now drop the subject and move on … You will have to find another “proof” to show Isa (AS) has died, because this one is not it …