Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders
How does one ‘come and go’ ? What does that ‘came and gone’ mean when it was used for prophets? 1) before Muhammad PBUH, 2 ) before Isa a.s. ?
The term qad khalat is not a rocket science as you’re implying it to be. Even like the way you are explaining it, it still means the same thing. Look at your history of prophets that have come and gone, (by getting killed and by dying a natural death). If Muhammad PBUH ‘come and go’ the same way, then will you turn your back on him (s.a.w).? That is how it is.
Lets take your explanation for the other verse as well. Look at the history of prophets that have come and gone before Jesus a.s. Jesus a.s was a prophet just like those who have come and gone. His mother was a truthful woman. Both, Jesus a.s and His mother used to eat. If we consider prophets BEFORE Isa a.s to have come and gone, and take that come and gone to mean passed away(in english or even in urdu it means died), then the verse says Jesus a.s was a prophet just like them. If they all died, then so did Jesus a.s, as Allah is not making any exception here. He is including jesus a.s with all those prophets who passed away.
He used to eat. You insist in saying that he ‘ate’ food and that the quality of ‘eating’ makes im mortal and not anything like Deity. If he ate food, and if he is NOT eating food now, then it automatically makes him someone like Deity! ( if hes not dead ). You forget about the other side of the verse completely. You say one thing and then cannot back it up with anything.
If he a.s is not eating, and Allah says he alone is the one who is paak from this, then you are associating partner with Allah!!