Details of interpreting verses from the Qur'an and obvious blunders

[psyah]

Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders

@Mr.Popat

I find your responses very amusing. You do not care one bit which side of an extreme you’re going to, just to defend your baseless belief.

This is not my criteria that someone who does not die is to be a God and God alone. It is not me saying it. Allah has set forth this condition. I urge you to read the verse. Therein lies all your answers. So clear that you need not to go anywhere else to know that Jesus a.s just like any other messenger died, and he used to eat, just like any other prophet used to eat.

So, I suggest you spend some time in pondering over the verse rather than coming up with some random stuff. God does not die and he does not eat. Messengers die and they also eat.. therefore, none of them can be called God. If you take out exception from it and say Jesus a.s is the only messenger who is still alive, then you must believe in Him as someone superior than a messenger. What part of it is hard to understand ?

**He a.s is either alive or hes dead. **

For him to be alive 1 ) He must be on Earth. Theres no life outside of Earth for a human being 2) He must be eating food. For Allah never sent a single messenger who never used to eat food. Human who eat food, gets old and eventually die.. ( death in a form of I) killing, II) passing away ). 3) He must be getting old.

5:75 is a pretty self explanatory verse.. which requires not paragraphs after paragraphs of explanation. Remember the criteria of ever living being God is set by none other than God himself. Everything everywhere in this universe if for a temporary period except Him.

Peace Mr.Popat

You take me for a fool? It is you who are regurgitating the insufficient arguments of people like the late Mirza Tahir Sahib … Your 4th Khalifa …

We don’t believe Isa (as) is immortal … We believe he will die … But we don’t believe he had died yet … And this third option is constantly being ignored by you.

Even if we take Isa (AS) to be living forever it cannot happen without the permission of Allah (SWT) and the verse given by kchughtai proves that it is possible … When Allah (SWT) said, and we did not grant anyone eternal life before you …tafsir mention it is meant in the context of Earthly eternal life … And secondly we can see that Allah (SWT) CAN grant this, but chose not to …

you have no leg to stand on … And you are arguing for no reason … !