Details of interpreting verses from the Qur'an and obvious blunders

[psyah]

Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders

@kchughtai

Psyah,

**21:34) WE granted not everlasting life to any mortal before thee. If you shouldst die, shall they live for ever?

**When the Almighty Himself said so then who are you to raise such an absurd question.

What is immortality? Immortal is the one who does not die and this attribute of Allah is highlighted in the following verse.

**25:58) And rely on the Ever-living Who dies not, and celebrate His praise; and Sufficient is He as being aware of the faults of His servants,

**

Yes. so it is very clear that the only **possible immortality comes after death. **

sorry for jumping. pls continue

Peace kchughtai

Tafsir state that the ayat is referring to everlasting life in this world …

Tafsir Ibn Kathir → Surah Al-Anbiya → No One has been granted Immortality in this World

And your statement that I have made in red … Of course it does … I was never saying that immortality comes before death … LOL that would be logically unsound …

I was saying since after death immortality is given to the selected creation of God, it follows that therefore immortality on its own is not the criteria for Divine Attribute … But rather how that immortality comes … Is it inherent or is it from God? … And it is that type of immortality that none other has dominion over that is reserved for Allah (SWT) … He is inherently Eternal, but He can induce His Creation to live eternally too. But you see all of this was hypothetical to prove a point … No one says that Isa (AS) is living forever … Merely a long time before his death … And it is highly likely that that time duration is only be experienced by us and not by him (AS) at all.