Details of interpreting verses from the Qur'an and obvious blunders

[Mr.Popat]

Re: Details of interpreting verses from the Qur’an and obvious blunders

@psyah

Peace Bigboi

If someone ate food and never died can he claim to be God? What does it say in your aqeedah? For us eating food is a sign of being mortal … not being self-subsistent … eating food means one takes nourishment from something else other than what is within it … Even if that entity did not die … the true Muslims will never claim it to be God … because they know that God does not eat … so understand! You have no argument here … If Allah (SWT) so Wills He can keep Isa (AS) alive forever just like He promises to keep the jannatis alive forever …

You are fixated over one semi-aspect of Divine attribute … Allah (SWT) has no beginning, no mother, no end, does not eat … Muslims believe that Isa (AS) will eventually die, hada mother and ate food … even if we don’t believe him to die at all it takes nothing away from Allah (SWT) because the everlasting life of Allah (SWT) is within the Being of Allah … but if anything lives forever that is not Allah (SWT) it can only do so by Allah (SWT) providing that sustaining power.

You need to understand tawheed properly … and I recommend your leaders who bring this stale argument to do the same …

Lets refer back to the verse again and talk to me from the verse. You need to realize the points that Allah is raising..

5:75 : The Messiah, son of Mary, was not but a messenger; [other] messengers have passed on before him. And his mother was a supporter of truth. They both used to eat food. Look how We make clear to them the signs; then look how they are deluded.

Look what Allah is saying.. its not about him alive for so many years making him God. Thats not the point this verse is making. 2 things needs to be understood in this verse. Eating and being alive. it is not me saying that if u dont do these 2 things, u can be god.. but rather god himself saying it. If Jesus used to eat like other messengers, he has died like other messengers as well..since God does not eat , nor does he die, Jesus cannot be God. Now tell me where am i making mistake ?

I cannot even believe what you said in bold red font. You telling me to understand tawheed? I tell you a basic meaning of what tawheed is.. it is to not associate any partner with Allah. It is to not say that such and such attributes can also be found in another person OTHER than GOD. I cant believe you’re not even thinking what you’re saying. Allah alone is immortal. There are attributes of Him which are only specific to Allah alone. If you say or believe anyone can get those attributes, is associating partner with Him. I warn you to ask for pardon from Allah for what you wrote.

Messengers like Messiah have died..and Messiah son of Mary was just a messenger like others. He cannot be God, since God never dies.
Messiah used to eat food.. Allah is paak from this.. He cannot be God since God never eats.

It is not about what my aqeedah is. One thing for certain is that all humans are mortal ! each one of us require food to eat, and die eventually. Same was the case with Jesus a.s as is clear from the verse. I dont know why you would even start to argue on this just for the sake of it.

But i still want a reasonable explanation of this verse from your side. Tell me what allah meant to say ‘used to eat’ and that messengers like him have passed away.. ?

According to you , in that verse, Does Allah mean He a.s used to eat .. but allah doesnt eat.. He a.s is still alive and so is allah?